Is Amir Khan Is A Younger Version Of De La Hoya Stylistally? - Page 2

Thread Stealer

Oscar was dropped early in his career by Valenzuela and Campanella. There were questions early on about his chin.

He took shots better as he moved up in weight. He was very big at the lower divisions, so presumably cutting less weight improved his punch resistance.

BoxingGenius27

Quote:

Originally Posted by ThePhantom5

Sweat Pea has a knockdown on Oscar.

I was thinking Narciso Valenzuela. De La Hoya went on to stop him shortly after. I knew it was against a weak opponent though.

BoxingGenius27

Quote:

Originally Posted by PED User

Oscar was dropped early in his career by Valenzuela and Campanella. There were questions early on about his chin.

He took shots better as he moved up in weight. He was very big at the lower divisions, so presumably cutting less weight improved his punch resistance.

Yep, you're right Campanella was the other one. They were both flash knockdowns, he was never really seriously hurt or in trouble though...

Khan on the other hand....

Light_Speed

No Linares' style is closer to young Oscar's.

Dominicano Soy

He's the closest thing to one, but he's still far from it. Unlike Khan, Oscar knew when to plant his feet, Oscar wasn't nearly as bouncy. He was also a much better counter puncher. Khan can still learn, reach that/ or go beyond that level (I doubt it though). We'll just have to see.

Eaner0919

Quote:

Originally Posted by Light_Speed

No Linares' style is closer to young Oscar's.

this is spot on

people forget what type of fighter Oscar was early on or maybe just too new of a boxing fan to realize how much of a bad ass early Oscar was. The man was a predator aggressively targeting his opponents but with skill and talent. He didn't just look for opportunities he made them on his own

once he moved to 147 it changed a bit. For some reason he wanted to eschew what made him such a stellar fighter, aggressiveness and a jack hammer left hook. That version is more like Khan but early Oscar, say from 140 down where I think he was something like 24-0 21KOs, is more like what Linares is

Dominicano Soy

Quote:

Originally Posted by Light_Speed

No Linares' style is closer to young Oscar's.

Sometimes I forget about Linares...

BoxingGenius27

Quote:

Originally Posted by Eaner0919

this is spot on

people forget what type of fighter Oscar was early on or maybe just too new of a boxing fan to realize how much of a bad ass early Oscar was. The man was a predator aggressively targeting his opponents but with skill and talent. He didn't just look for opportunities he made them on his own

once he moved to 147 it changed a bit. For some reason he wanted to eschew what made him such a stellar fighter, aggressiveness and a jack hammer left hook. That version is more like Khan but early Oscar, say from 140 down where I think he was something like 24-0 21KOs, is more like what Linares is

Sylistically, I can see Linares having similar attributes, but not as close as Khan. Here's why. Khan comes out just as dangerous as a young Oscar who mixes it up just as well. Look at the Salita fight. Khan came out with cruel intentions, similar to a young hungry DLH.

But, it's the jab that pulls Khan closer to DLH for me. Linares has a pretty good jab from what I've seen, but it's not nearly as laser sharp or effective as Khans. You combine that with how Khan looks during exchanges and it's pretty obvious in my opinion.

I'll have to watch Linares more. But for some reason, speed/jab wise, he never rubbed me as being similar to DLH. I'll have to review more of his fights though...

_original_

I just don't see it

Jury

I see no resemblance what so ever!

Thread Stealer Undisputed Champion Join Date: Sep 2007 Posts: 9,455 Rep Power: 29 Points: 40,981,611.06 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 40,981,611.06 Donate	Oscar was dropped early in his career by Valenzuela and Campanella. There were questions early on about his chin. He took shots better as he moved up in weight. He was very big at the lower divisions, so presumably cutting less weight improved his punch resistance.

Light_Speed SPEED IS POWER Join Date: Sep 2010 Posts: 8,308 Rep Power: 42 Points: 84,042,269,023.11 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 84,042,269,023.11 Donate	No Linares' style is closer to young Oscar's.

Dominicano Soy The Problem Join Date: Apr 2009 Location: Bronx, New York Age: 24 Posts: 25,540 Blog Entries: 1 Rep Power: 65 Points: 30,132,355,895.45 Bank: 1,094,612,499,638.02 Total Points: 1,124,744,855,533.48 Donate	He's the closest thing to one, but he's still far from it. Unlike Khan, Oscar knew when to plant his feet, Oscar wasn't nearly as bouncy. He was also a much better counter puncher. Khan can still learn, reach that/ or go beyond that level (I doubt it though). We'll just have to see.

_original_ Boxingscene's Reckoning Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Denver Posts: 6,063 Rep Power: 16 Points: 124,336,286,854.14 Bank: 650,422,245.84 Total Points: 124,986,709,099.98 Donate	I just don't see it

Jury trial horse Join Date: Mar 2007 Posts: 1,643 Rep Power: 49 Points: 2,744.05 Bank: 154,459,353,391.02 Total Points: 154,459,356,135.07 Donate	I see no resemblance what so ever!