Should Ricky Hatton go into the Hall of Fame? - Page 3

Mojo Jojo

Quote:

Originally Posted by shade darkar

he didnt? care to elaborate? ring magazine champ from 2005-2009 no?

And who did he beat when he reigned as "King" during 2005-2009?

Carlos Moussa and Juan Urango.... My god. What an impressive reign as the king.

Vegan101

A shoo-in as a hall of famer in 2 - 3 years.

Since 1985

I would say yes, in large part due to his dominance at 140lbs., he was undefeated there except for the KO loss to Pacquiao. He sparked Tszyu and Castillo in tremendous fashion.

ThePhantom5

stevemaxboxing Steve Kim on whether or not Hatton deserves to be in the HOF.
@TheRealPhantom5 - IMO, no

shade darkar

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mojo Jojo

And who did he beat when he reigned as "King" during 2005-2009?

Carlos Moussa and Juan Urango.... My god. What an impressive reign as the king.

i didnt ask you who he beat. i stated that he ruled a division for 4 years, which he did! nobody was ranked higher than hatton at 140 for 4 years. so whos the idiot now?

Mojo Jojo

Quote:

Originally Posted by shade darkar

i didnt ask you who he beat. i stated that he ruled a division for 4 years, which he did! nobody was ranked higher than hatton at 140 for 4 years. so whos the idiot now?

Think, goddamnit, think.

Why was he #1, in the first place? For beating Tszyu who was clearly not the same fighter anymore. His whole 2005-2009 ranking was based on that. Absolutely ridiculous.

shade darkar

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mojo Jojo

Think, goddamnit, think.

Why was he #1, in the first place? For beating Tszyu who was clearly not the same fighter anymore. His whole 2005-2009 ranking was based on that. Absolutely ridiculous.

if you think you can be the number 1 for 4 years on the back of just 1 win then that says it all. anyway my only point was that he was the number 1 junior welterweight for 4 years which you said he wasnt.

-Antonio-

No he doesn't. Beating an old injury plagued and inactive Tszyu does not make you a hall of famer. Tszyu who himself was overrated. Tszyu who was coming off wins against the killers known as Ben Tackie and Sharmba Mitchell.

Clyde Barrow

Not complaining if he gets in. But I'm not sure if he should. He had a good run while he was around. He's best known for Kostya of course, then for his 2 losses, which were nothing to be ashamed of. He got a couple good wins as a champion but nothing too amazing.

-Kev-

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mojo Jojo

He did not rule a division for 4 years, you idiot.

Look at Hatton, the mighty WBU champion.

.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mojo Jojo

No way.

This guy was defending the friggin' WBU belt for many years against total bums. He got beat by Collazo and got totally annihilated by the P4P best boxers in the world. The only legit opponent he beat was, Paul Malignaggi.

Hatton doesn't deserve to get in the HOF.

I bet you just learned Ricky Hatton was the 140 Ring champion today and you're just trying to play it off now.

Let me ask you, do you think Kostya Tszyu deserves to be in the HOF? He was the 140 champion for 4 years and his best win was against Zab Judah, and his best name is a past prime JCC. He was beat by Phillips and Hatton. Hatton was beat by much better fighters in Mayweather and Pacquiao, two fighters considered top 50 ATG's by some historians. Can you tell me what is the shame in losing to two of the best top 50 fighters in history? The same guy you're dissing, wiped the floor with Tszyu and ruled the same division for the same amount of time. And Collazo did not beat Hatton.

Hatton is a former Ring & lineal 140 champ, former WBA 140 champion, former IBF 140 champ, former WBA 147 champ, and let me add he once held The Ring/Lineal/WBA/IBF titles all at once at 140.

But answer my question though, does Zoo belong in the HOF?

View Poll Results: Should Ricky Hatton be voted into the Hall of Fame?
Yes	97	51.05%
No	93	48.95%
Voters: 190. You may not vote on this poll

Vegan101 Banned Join Date: May 2010 Location: London, England Age: 20 Posts: 2,704 Rep Power: 0 Points: 22,569,834.97 Bank: 90,242,751,310.74 Total Points: 90,265,321,145.71 Donate	A shoo-in as a hall of famer in 2 - 3 years.

Since 1985 Since 1895 Join Date: Oct 2010 Location: Inglewood, CA Age: 28 Posts: 3,867 Rep Power: 10 Points: 1,027,920,805,838.67 Bank: 292,510,194.99 Total Points: 1,028,213,316,033.66 Donate	I would say yes, in large part due to his dominance at 140lbs., he was undefeated there except for the KO loss to Pacquiao. He sparked Tszyu and Castillo in tremendous fashion.

ThePhantom5 The Boss Join Date: Nov 2009 Location: State College, PA Posts: 21,574 Rep Power: 73 Points: 19,816,998,473.93 Bank: 864,501,061,195.84 Total Points: 884,318,059,669.77 Donate	stevemaxboxing Steve Kim on whether or not Hatton deserves to be in the HOF. @TheRealPhantom5 - IMO, no

-Antonio- -Antonio- Join Date: Jun 2005 Posts: 23,176 Rep Power: 83 Points: 7,288,955.81 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 7,288,955.81 Donate	No he doesn't. Beating an old injury plagued and inactive Tszyu does not make you a hall of famer. Tszyu who himself was overrated. Tszyu who was coming off wins against the killers known as Ben Tackie and Sharmba Mitchell.

Clyde Barrow King of the Castle Join Date: May 2009 Location: a happy home Posts: 7,227 Rep Power: 26 Points: 9,602.50 Bank: 8,149,691,683.95 Total Points: 8,149,701,286.45 Donate	Not complaining if he gets in. But I'm not sure if he should. He had a good run while he was around. He's best known for Kostya of course, then for his 2 losses, which were nothing to be ashamed of. He got a couple good wins as a champion but nothing too amazing.