Was Grandpa shane the biggest challenge atWelter Floyd has fought?

Alibata

Even @ his older age he is still better than, Judah, Baldomir, Hatton, Marquez, mitchell. If he fought Ortiz, Ortiz would be the 2nd biggest challenge at 147 for Floyd.

Still Blazin

That Grandpa Shane was the P4P Number 3 fighter in ALL of boxing and the Number 1 WW.

So obviously yes.

ThePhantom5

Quote:

Originally Posted by No Ceilings

That Grandpa Shane was the P4P Number 3 fighter in ALL of boxing and the Number 1 WW.

So obviously yes.

End thread.

Bushbaby

Yes,an old Mosley was.

Alibata

Quote:

Originally Posted by No Ceilings

That Grandpa Shane was the P4P Number 3 fighter in ALL of boxing and the Number 1 WW.

So obviously yes.

Does # for # count though... Obviously it does but I see a lot of people discrediting Pacs wins over Barrera, Morales, Cotto, Hatton who were lb for lb fighters when they were defeated.

Twako

Quote:

Originally Posted by No Ceilings

That Grandpa Shane was the P4P Number 3 fighter in ALL of boxing and the Number 1 WW.

So obviously yes.

alright then, what a hollow career.

ThePhantom5

Quote:

Originally Posted by Twako

alright then, what a hollow career.

Yes . His career at WW is all that counts.

Lets judge all fighters by only one of the weight classes they fought at.

Brilliant logic.

Still Blazin

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alibata

Does # for # count though... Obviously it does but I see a lot of people discrediting Pacs wins over Barrera, Morales, Cotto, Hatton who were lb for lb fighters when they were defeated.

Who on here has EVER discredited Pac for beating Barerra? I have NEVER seen that. MAB was the P4P Number 3 just like Shane was.

Cotto wasnt P4P. Neither was Hatton.

Morales wasnt either. He had just got destroyed by Rahemm.

Still Blazin

Quote:

Originally Posted by ThePhantom5

Yes . His career at WW is all that counts.

Lets judge all fighters by only one of the weight classes they fought at.

Brilliant logic.

I wonder do most people who hate on Floyd realize that 31 out of his 41 fights were fought at 135 or under.

Thats 90% of his fights.

Yup lets only his judge his WW run.

Twako

Quote:

Originally Posted by ThePhantom5

Yes . His career at WW is all that counts.

Lets judge all fighters by only one of the weight classes they fought at.

Brilliant logic.

yes, his career in the last 5-6years was what i was referring about.

Alibata Dugong Maharlika Join Date: May 2004 Posts: 9,402 Rep Power: 38 Points: 6,321,352.92 Bank: 3,016,552,922.79 Total Points: 3,022,874,275.71 Donate	Was Grandpa shane the biggest challenge atWelter Floyd has fought? Even @ his older age he is still better than, Judah, Baldomir, Hatton, Marquez, mitchell. If he fought Ortiz, Ortiz would be the 2nd biggest challenge at 147 for Floyd.

Still Blazin Banned Join Date: Feb 2010 Posts: 34,135 Rep Power: 0 Points: 14,210,260,354.52 Bank: 288,283,432,102.74 Total Points: 302,493,692,457.26 Donate	That Grandpa Shane was the P4P Number 3 fighter in ALL of boxing and the Number 1 WW. So obviously yes.

Bushbaby The Novelist. Join Date: Dec 2008 Location: Zion bound. By way of St Croix. Posts: 19,069 Blog Entries: 1 Rep Power: 47 Points: 921,391,820.08 Bank: 183,163,245,714.39 Total Points: 184,084,637,534.47 Donate	Yes,an old Mosley was.