Most individual scorecards you've ever seen? - Page 2

fitefanSHO

Jo Jo Guerra

118-110 for Leonard over Hagler

yuppie

You guys have got to watch the prize fighter tourneys in the UK because you will see some shocking scores. This isnt really on topic but i did laugh when i saw elie sechback score of the Rios/Acosta fight.

El C@cique@PR

Casamayor 114-113 over Santa Cruz, when Casamayor didnt won a single round, that was disgusting!!!!!

DTanc

This past Friday on ESPN Friday Night Fights my friend Patrick Lopez lost a competitive decision to Hank Lundy. After Lundy scored a knockdown in the 4th he spent much of the fight running away. I had Lundy winning the 1-4, then Patrick winning 5-9 and I thought Lundy turned it on enough in the 10th & final round to take that one. So I had it 5 to 5, with the knockdown Lundy scored that'd be 95-94 for Lundy, which is exactly what Judge Peter Hary scored it.

Judge Robert Paolino scored the fight 99-91 giving Patrick only one round. I agree he lost, but one round is literally impossible and Hank would tell you that himself. It was an entertaining fight, not a one-way whitewash.

Paolino is probably a whore on Jimmy Burchfield's payroll.

Yeah, I'm a lil bitter.

minasyan

Kotelnik vs Alexander, this was shocking

referee: Vic Drakulich | judge: Jerry Roth 112-116 | judge: Oren Shellenberger 112-116 | judge: Denny Nelson 112-116

*Khan

Quote:

Originally Posted by yuppie

You guys have got to watch the prize fighter tourneys in the UK because you will see some shocking scores. This isnt really on topic but i did laugh when i saw elie sechback score of the Rios/Acosta fight.

Not shocking considering Ellie practically lives in Rios' gym.

Scott9945

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steak

What is the biggest screw up youve seen a boxing judge make? Doesnt start naming BS in close fights that could go either way, Im talking about a scorecard that is simply completely off point.

the worst for me is Christian Mijares vs Jose Navarro.
Doug Tucker scored it 120-108 for Navarro when Mijares had a very obvious victory. a shut out for the guy that clearly lost? how is this even excusable? the guy needs to be banned from scoring fights.

share your own.

The fight you mentioned was probably the most bizzare. I'm still waiting to hear that the ring announcer read it wrong.

fitefanSHO KO Digest Join Date: Mar 2011 Location: BOSTON Posts: 1,414 Rep Power: 5 Points: 1,076,697.96 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 1,076,697.96 Donate	Jo Jo Guerra 118-110 for Leonard over Hagler

yuppie Undisputed Champion Join Date: Apr 2010 Posts: 1,725 Rep Power: 7 Points: 1,000,084,911.76 Bank: 5,234,620,344.95 Total Points: 6,234,705,256.71 Donate	You guys have got to watch the prize fighter tourneys in the UK because you will see some shocking scores. This isnt really on topic but i did laugh when i saw elie sechback score of the Rios/Acosta fight.

El C@cique@PR El Jibaro Mal Criao Join Date: Apr 2010 Posts: 5,863 Rep Power: 17 Points: 1,009,930,152.62 Bank: 8,877,239,601.72 Total Points: 9,887,169,754.34 Donate	Casamayor 114-113 over Santa Cruz, when Casamayor didnt won a single round, that was disgusting!!!!!

minasyan Undisputed Champion Join Date: Nov 2008 Posts: 1,005 Rep Power: 7 Points: 21,879.38 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 21,879.38 Donate	Kotelnik vs Alexander, this was shocking referee: Vic Drakulich \| judge: Jerry Roth 112-116 \| judge: Oren Shellenberger 112-116 \| judge: Denny Nelson 112-116