Which Mayweather Fight Made Him An All-Time Great? - Page 3

daggum

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Gambler1981

Almost guaranteed all those guys get in.

The Hall of Fame is more of a popularity contest and with Genaro he is going to get a lot of sympathy votes going forward when you consider his battle with cancer.

why would genaro get in? look at his resume. he's not even close. the only sure fire hall of famers mayweather has is marquez, mosley and delahoya. 2 of those guys were at the end of their careers and marquez was way above his best weight.

revs1227

dlh and hatton where both very! live in those fights unlike theyre pacquiao fights
so id say hatton imo he was a BEAST in tht fight and mayweather was the only man i can think of to beat him that night

miron_lang

Floyd looks like Roy Jones againts Philip Ndou.

I dont think Ndou landed a clear shot the whole fight.

Philip Ndou for me.

The Gambler1981

Quote:

Originally Posted by daggum

why would genaro get in? look at his resume. he's not even close. the only sure fire hall of famers mayweather has is marquez, mosley and delahoya. 2 of those guys were at the end of their careers and marquez was way above his best weight.

Sympathy votes~ he is a classy guy fighting a debilitating disease you are telling me the writers would not want to write about that (and that is who votes), and he was a fine fighter.

The other guys will all get in based on popularity and specific moments they are associated with.

The Gambler1981

The boxing Hall of Fame ain't that exclusive~

DR.ORGYY

Quote:

Originally Posted by walt liquor

sosa was one vote off last year. He's guaranteed next year.

Wait a second, isn't bruseles already in, i thiought he got in early

yea those guys are easily top 10 all time greats..............

Aut_72

How many times has this thread been made??

Why am I posting on this BS Thread??

Why am I asking so many questions??

Sugar Sting Ray

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Gambler1981

Floyd career as currently constructed is not about any one defining moment it is about consistency and longevity which are both very rare in boxing, there is more than one way to skin a cat~

Robinson had Basilio, Fullmer, and Lamotta.

Ali had Frazier, Liston, and Foreman.

Pacquiao had Barrera, Morales, and Marquez.

Leonard had Duran, Hearns, and Hagler.

Mayweather has N'dou, Corley, and Mitchell? Does not sound Sugar Ray Ali Pacquiao Leonard-like.

studentofthegam

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sugar Sting Ray

Which one will become a Hall of Famer first?

Glad you aint on the committee because it prolly wouldnt be any black faces in it huh Dave Duke?

Quote:

Originally Posted by IronDanHamza

It's unlikely any of those fighters will get into the HOF but they are all very good fighters and good solid wins for Mayweather.

Just when I think you had gone as far as you can go.

DLh, wont get in?
JMM wont get in?
Gatti wont get in?
WOW.

The Gambler1981

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sugar Sting Ray

Robinson had Basilio, Fullmer, and Lamotta.

Ali had Frazier, Liston, and Foreman.

Pacquiao had Barrera, Morales, and Marquez.

Leonard had Duran, Hearns, and Hagler.

Mayweather has N'dou, Corley, and Mitchell? Does not sound Sugar Ray Ali Pacquiao Leonard-like.

Pacquaio ain't close to those dudes either

Barrera was distracted the first fight (kidnapping) and the second fight lol

Morales Manny lost to the best version he faced not impressive

JMM- The first fight was an embarrassment no way you should let that fight slip away, the second one was his best win.

It doesn't stack up~ Manny is in the same boat as Floyd longevity is why he is on the list also

revs1227 Undisputed Champion Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: OZONE PARK QUEENS NEW YORK CITY Age: 25 Posts: 7,267 Rep Power: 25 Points: 3,294,222,740.29 Bank: 14,784,094,454.31 Total Points: 18,078,317,194.60 Donate	dlh and hatton where both very! live in those fights unlike theyre pacquiao fights so id say hatton imo he was a BEAST in tht fight and mayweather was the only man i can think of to beat him that night

miron_lang Banned Join Date: Feb 2004 Posts: 6,940 Blog Entries: 3 Rep Power: 14429 Points: 3,403,299,205.56 Bank: 9,488,298,954,932.27 Total Points: 9,491,702,254,137.84 Donate	Floyd looks like Roy Jones againts Philip Ndou. I dont think Ndou landed a clear shot the whole fight. Philip Ndou for me.

The Gambler1981 Undisputed Champion Join Date: May 2008 Location: Detroit Age: 32 Posts: 16,654 Rep Power: 44 Points: 600,049,496.06 Bank: 73,291,230,088.52 Total Points: 73,891,279,584.58 Donate $\m/ - Kenny MF Powers$	The boxing Hall of Fame ain't that exclusive~

Aut_72 Contender Join Date: Feb 2010 Posts: 355 Rep Power: 0 Points: 15,614.30 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 15,614.30 Donate	How many times has this thread been made?? Why am I posting on this BS Thread?? Why am I asking so many questions??