Why is Nonito Donaire rated so highly by The Ring? - Page 2

Rome-By-Ko

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyBoxing

He's betta P4P than Shotsley and Williams.

Mosley and Willaims have way better names on their resume..They should be on the P4P list based on resume alone..

Rome-By-Ko

I can name at least three fighters who should be there instead of Donaire..

1.Bradley
2.Froch
3.Ward
4.JML/R.marquez

cleaner147

when did he lose the last time..........
first man to stop Vic who was the Tacco-eater NR1...........

very exciting to watch with much left.........you will know sonn why hes so high rated.............he beats Montiel anytime.

Rome-By-Ko

Quote:

Originally Posted by MAЯA

when did he lose the last time..........
first man to stop Vic who was the Tacco-eater NR1...........

very exciting to watch with much left.........you will know sonn why hes so high rated.............he beats Montiel anytime.

When he does he will deserve it a lil more then at the moment is all..How is he so highly rank over guys who have fought better Competition then him??

cleaner147

Quote:

Originally Posted by romebyko

When he does he will deserve it a lil more then at the moment is all..How is he so highly rank over guys who have fought better Competition then him??

c'mon what do you want to hear from me?

hes over-hyped to sh1t cuz he was a Pinoy in Pacmachine's era.............

no man he beat the man that was to beat who beat all these stone-lifters......and that in a ****in impression way. and still impresses and the big fights will come soon for him.....you will see

Rome-By-Ko

Quote:

Originally Posted by MAЯA

c'mon what do you want to hear from me?

hes over-hyped to sh1t cuz he was a Pinoy in Pacmachine's era.............

no man he beat the man that was to beat who beat all these stone-lifters......and that in a ****in impression way. and still impresses and the big fights will come soon for him.....you will see

I don't want you to bad mouth the kid,hell I'm not bad mouthing him either I think he is a really good boxer..All I'm saying is his resume is shaky..Chinny was not on the P4P ranking when he lost to Donaire,but yet Donaire has been rank without having faced a real challenge..I don't know if he does not belong on the P4P list cause he has not fought a fighter on his level since Chinny,but TBH there are other fighters who deserve it more...

Sweet Jesus

Because The Ring is biased towards West Coast fighters.

Sweet Jesus

Quote:

Originally Posted by romebyko

I can name at least three fighters who should be there instead of Donaire..

1.Bradley
2.Froch
3.Ward
4.JML/R.marquez

Did you just say that Carl Froch belongs in the Ring top 10?

Logout and never post again.

Dirty cunt.

RwK

What I've come to realize...........is the Ring rankings aren't really overly concerned with focusing on a boxer's resume in whole. It's more of a subjective approach where they view the Boxer's abilities and critique from what they see from him.

Because in the past I've been shocked at who they rank on their "P4P" lists but oh well. It's not the end of the damn world.

Plus I don't follow Ring.

RwK

Quote:

Originally Posted by romebyko

Mosley and Willaims have way better names on their resume..They should be on the P4P list based on resume alone..

It's been established that "P4P" lists aren't definitive anyways. It's merely an outlet for people to end up arguing who they believe the better fighter is, and most of the time everyone is dead wrong.

I mean lol there are people who put Heavyweights on a P4P list even though they're the supreme weight. So what does that say?

Rome-By-Ko Matthysse beat Judah!! Join Date: Mar 2009 Posts: 15,410 Blog Entries: 3 Rep Power: 39 Points: 18,714,493,480.23 Bank: 3,520,316,996,748.79 Total Points: 3,539,031,490,229.02 Donate	I can name at least three fighters who should be there instead of Donaire.. 1.Bradley 2.Froch 3.Ward 4.JML/R.marquez

cleaner147 Retired Join Date: Nov 2009 Posts: 5,008 Rep Power: 15 Points: 2,294,235.82 Bank: 0.01 Total Points: 2,294,235.83 Donate	when did he lose the last time.......... first man to stop Vic who was the Tacco-eater NR1........... very exciting to watch with much left.........you will know sonn why hes so high rated.............he beats Montiel anytime.

Sweet Jesus Banned Join Date: Dec 2009 Posts: 12,894 Rep Power: 0 Points: 66,393.80 Bank: 377,042,332.67 Total Points: 377,108,726.47 Donate	Because The Ring is biased towards West Coast fighters.

RwK Predator Hunts My Love Join Date: Feb 2005 Location: I die, Valkyrie takes me Posts: 65,123 Blog Entries: 5 Rep Power: 16910 Points: 6,631,347,378.91 Bank: 215,261,032.56 Total Points: 6,846,608,411.48 Donate	What I've come to realize...........is the Ring rankings aren't really overly concerned with focusing on a boxer's resume in whole. It's more of a subjective approach where they view the Boxer's abilities and critique from what they see from him. Because in the past I've been shocked at who they rank on their "P4P" lists but oh well. It's not the end of the damn world. Plus I don't follow Ring.