Why is Nonito Donaire rated so highly by The Ring?

elgranluchadore

this i not a hate thread to pinoys or anything i just dont get it, sure his win against vic was good but enough to bring him into the p4p list?
and once he got there can anyone care to explain how he got all the way up there without beating any ranked fighters, even vic wasnt on the list when donaire beat him
IMO montiel has a much better resume and better wins and hes a legit 3 time world champion unlike donaire who got a paper belt in the superflyweights without beating nashiro or vic again who were the true wba 115 champions

Left Hook Tua

they like his skills?

p4p is not just about resume. it's about skills and potential too.

elgranluchadore

Quote:

Originally Posted by Left Hook Tua

they like his skills?

p4p is not just about resume. it's about skills and potential too.

skills at what man? i mean if looking great against sub par competition vitali and wlad should be topping the list
vargas marquez and that poor guy who was undefeated were hardly quality opponents not to mention he looked akward against concepcion and just plain bad against that south african guy
still at least the guys at the lower weights are getting recognition i thought hell froze over when they rated pong
the ring seemed to forget about the little guys in the 2000s the last rated guys i remember where arbachakov and mark johnson

Steelhammer2011

because he is an American citizen.

Left Hook Tua

Quote:

Originally Posted by elgranluchadore

skills at what man? i mean if looking great against sub par competition vitali and wlad should be topping the list
vargas marquez and that poor guy who was undefeated were hardly quality opponents not to mention he looked akward against concepcion and just plain bad against that south african guy
still at least the guys at the lower weights are getting recognition i thought hell froze over when they rated pong
the ring seemed to forget about the little guys in the 2000s the last rated guys i remember where arbachakov and mark johnson

i think vitali and wlad is worthy of top 10 p4p

Left Hook Tua

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steelhammer2010

because he is an American citizen.

6 of the top 10 isn't american , ДУРАК.

BillyBoxing

Quote:

Originally Posted by elgranluchadore

this i not a hate thread to pinoys or anything i just dont get it, sure his win against vic was good but enough to bring him into the p4p list?
and once he got there can anyone care to explain how he got all the way up there without beating any ranked fighters, even vic wasnt on the list when donaire beat him
IMO montiel has a much better resume and better wins and hes a legit 3 time world champion unlike donaire who got a paper belt in the superflyweights without beating nashiro or vic again who were the true wba 115 champions

He's betta P4P than Shotsley and Williams.

IMDAZED

Quote:

Originally Posted by Left Hook Tua

i think vitali and wlad is worthy of top 10 p4p

Vitali isn't worth sniffing the top ten. Wlad should be in the 3-7 range.

Rome-By-Ko

Who knows but the one thing I do know he does not deserve it..His biggest win to date was Chinny and that's not saying very much..

IMDAZED

Quote:

Originally Posted by romebyko

Who knows but the one thing I do know he does not deserve it..His biggest win to date was Chinny and that's not saying very much..

Yeah Donaire should NOT be on the list. Just mind boggling.

Left Hook Tua PARTY LIKE IT'S 1996 Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: Anaheim, CA Posts: 67,042 Rep Power: 182 Points: 111,703.71 Bank: 11,493,117,379,640.87 Total Points: 11,493,117,491,344.58 Donate	they like his skills? p4p is not just about resume. it's about skills and potential too.

Steelhammer2011 Banned Join Date: Feb 2010 Posts: 2,166 Rep Power: 0 Points: 54,768.92 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 54,768.92 Donate	because he is an American citizen.

Rome-By-Ko Matthysse beat Judah!! Join Date: Mar 2009 Posts: 15,380 Blog Entries: 3 Rep Power: 39 Points: 20,914,492,512.62 Bank: 3,383,618,797,336.40 Total Points: 3,404,533,289,849.02 Donate	Who knows but the one thing I do know he does not deserve it..His biggest win to date was Chinny and that's not saying very much..