Which of these MWs/SMWs/LHWs deserve to go to HOF? - Page 2

oldgringo

Roy, Hopkins and Calzaghe.

Tarver is somewhat borderline, but on the outside looking in.

Shadows

Jones, Calzaghe, and Hopkins.

jayblack

Bernard, Joe, and Roy all go.

project xxx1

i gave it to griffen lol

EngorgedW/Blood

Taylor is one of my faves on that list but it's just too bad he was beaten by Pavlik twice, Froch and Abraham at a pretty young age, and badly too. I would understand if it was like Roy who started losing fights at mid 30s-late 30s after he already made his legendary move up to HW. But losing like that at late 20s-early 30s and just like 30 fights really hurts your chances at the HOF. I would also understand being 30 and being battle worn from 40-50 pro fights but 33 fights..na. Winky was a good fight but a draw, Hopkins were two good wins, Lacy was boarder line win, Ouma was an alright win, Joppy was an ok win, Raul Marquez was an ok win.

jrosales13

Jones, Hopkins, Calzaghe.

trk

Jones, Hopkins, and Calzaghe are in for sure. Taylor and Tarver are close, but probably just outside of where they need to be to get in the HOF. Kessler or Froch would be HOFers if they win the super 6 tournament.

View Poll Results: Which of these deserve to go into the HOF?
Jermain Taylor	0	0%
Bernard Hopkins	4	18.18%
Joe Calzaghe	2	9.09%
Roy Jones Jr	15	68.18%
Mikkel Kessler	0	0%
Antonio Tarver	0	0%
Glen Johnson	0	0%
Carl Froch	0	0%
Montell Griffin	1	4.55%
Jeff Lacy	0	0%
Voters: 22. You may not vote on this poll

oldgringo Ellis Join Date: Jul 2004 Location: The Deuce Posts: 22,968 Rep Power: 21528 Points: 743,128.12 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 743,128.12 Donate	Roy, Hopkins and Calzaghe. Tarver is somewhat borderline, but on the outside looking in.

Shadows All-Time Great Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Massachusetts Posts: 8,983 Blog Entries: 1 Rep Power: 22 Points: 1,151,453,655.05 Bank: 104,565,490,871.72 Total Points: 105,716,944,526.77 Donate	Jones, Calzaghe, and Hopkins.

jayblack Interim Champion Join Date: Dec 2006 Posts: 558 Rep Power: 0 Points: 45,670.28 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 45,670.28 Donate	Bernard, Joe, and Roy all go.

project xxx1 Undisputed Champion Join Date: Jul 2009 Posts: 15,447 Rep Power: 41 Points: 1,678,477.46 Bank: 3,225,656,041,546.26 Total Points: 3,225,657,720,023.72 Donate	i gave it to griffen lol

jrosales13 undisputed champion Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: Converse TX Age: 29 Posts: 33,039 Rep Power: 76 Points: 383,418,912,304.24 Bank: 2.21 Total Points: 383,418,912,306.45 Donate	Jones, Hopkins, Calzaghe.

trk Contender Join Date: Apr 2010 Posts: 283 Rep Power: 4 Points: 10,478.49 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 10,478.49 Donate	Jones, Hopkins, and Calzaghe are in for sure. Taylor and Tarver are close, but probably just outside of where they need to be to get in the HOF. Kessler or Froch would be HOFers if they win the super 6 tournament.