Let's Be Real, Floyd Mayweather Would've Beaten Sugar Ray Robinson If They Fought - Page 2

F l i c k e r

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tengoshi

Mayweather appears thicker because he's able to add more muscle due to the practice of same-day weigh-ins no longer being in place. Robinson would appear closer to his middleweight body at WW fighting under today's rules.

Makes sense. I totally forgot about the rule change. I don't know about the muscle part but adding more weight makes sense.

Even then, it's not exactly easy to bully Mayweather around, his pocket fighting and strength is very good.

NChristo

I got Robinson.

NChristo

I like how the 3 people that voted Floyd have never come into BH before, have you ever even seen footage of Robinson at WW before ?.

Red Rebel

I hate it when people downplay too much the modern fighters, because of the love of the past favorite fighters. Boxing fans who have been watching it for 3-4 decades already barely accepts that the newer fighters can be as good sometimes better as the past boxers. However this time it's pretty obvious that the past boxer is absolutely better than the current.

SRR wins this one w/ authority.

TBear

What welterweight in his prime did Mayweather beat that gave the TS the idea he would stand a chance against Robinson. Actually the only Sugar Ray I'd give Floyd a chance against is Seales.

Kids these days!

GoogleMe

So you claim. But I'll just say the sport has evolved, I truly think, the technical level is much greater today then back then.

wmute

The display of ignorance in this thread is disgusting.

QADASHBANYAH1

Quote:

Originally Posted by GoogleMe

So you claim. But I'll just say the sport has evolved, I truly think, the technical level is much greater today then back then.

I think it is as well, I honestly feel just as in every other sport the athletes of today are better conditioned, and better trained with better technique, but they lack the strength of the old time favorites. The old days were a test as in survival was hard for most people.

Just like in the nfl, players would play with broken fingers without cortisone shots etc. THEY WERE JUST TOUGHER, AND DID A LOT MORE FOR LESS, SO YOU GOTTA LOVE EM.

I think floyd could hold his own though IMO.

We need a time machine to settle all this madness. lol.

poet682006

Quote:

Originally Posted by wmute

The display of ignorance in this thread is disgusting.

Yeah, retardation is a given when the drones from NSB come trickling into Boxing History. Typical fan-boi logic at work: Favorite active fighter = best fighter ever. Floyd beats a well past-it 38 year old Shane = Hagler beating Hearns. It's typical.

Poet

Roy Keane

would be intresting to see how ray would break floyds defense, id pick ray to win simply because i dont think floyd has the power to back ray up and potshotting just isnt enough against someone like robinson

View Poll Results: Who takes it?
Floyd "Money" Mayweather	29	19.73%
Sugar Ray Robinson	118	80.27%
Voters: 147. You may not vote on this poll

NChristo Morning Glory Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: Blackpool Posts: 4,875 Rep Power: 15 Points: 1,000,015,099.41 Bank: 453,337,161,798.55 Total Points: 454,337,176,897.96 Donate	I got Robinson.

Red Rebel sniper Join Date: Feb 2010 Posts: 1,434 Rep Power: 6 Points: 157,097.43 Bank: 63,844.43 Total Points: 220,941.86 Donate	I hate it when people downplay too much the modern fighters, because of the love of the past favorite fighters. Boxing fans who have been watching it for 3-4 decades already barely accepts that the newer fighters can be as good sometimes better as the past boxers. However this time it's pretty obvious that the past boxer is absolutely better than the current. SRR wins this one w/ authority.

TBear Lords of Boxingscene Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: In the shadows of your dreams Age: 89 Posts: 60,441 Rep Power: 323 Points: 2,697.38 Bank: 48,263,217,152,253.59 Total Points: 48,263,217,154,950.96 Donate	What welterweight in his prime did Mayweather beat that gave the TS the idea he would stand a chance against Robinson. Actually the only Sugar Ray I'd give Floyd a chance against is Seales. Kids these days!

GoogleMe Undisputed Champion Join Date: Sep 2009 Location: Denmark Posts: 3,512 Rep Power: 11 Points: 3,075.59 Bank: 1,201,688,900.69 Total Points: 1,201,691,976.28 Donate	So you claim. But I'll just say the sport has evolved, I truly think, the technical level is much greater today then back then.

wmute Undisputed Champion Join Date: Nov 2003 Posts: 8,020 Rep Power: 30 Points: 179,026.96 Bank: 2,446,065,647.73 Total Points: 2,446,244,674.69 Donate	The display of ignorance in this thread is disgusting.

Roy Keane Contender Join Date: Dec 2008 Posts: 467 Rep Power: 0 Points: 22,335.73 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 22,335.73 Donate	would be intresting to see how ray would break floyds defense, id pick ray to win simply because i dont think floyd has the power to back ray up and potshotting just isnt enough against someone like robinson