Who is the GREATER Fighter as of date?

[Castor_Troy]

Erik Morales

Notable Wins :


1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Marco Antonio Barrera
3. Junior Jones
4. Jesus Chavez
5. Daniel Zaragoza
6. In Jin Chi
7. Carlos Hernandez
8. Wayne McCullough
9. Paulie Ayala
10. Kevin Kelley
11. Gutty Espadas


Notable Losses :


1. Manny Pacquiao X2
2. Marco Antonio Barrera X2
3. Zaheer Raheem


Shane Mosley


Notable Wins :

1. Oscar Dela Hoya
2. Antonio Margarito
3. John John Molina
4. Jessie James Leija
5. Luis Collazo
6. Ricardo Mayorga
7. Golden Johnson
8. Fernando Vargas
9. Philip Holiday


Notable Losses :


1. Vernon Forrest X2
2. Winky Wright X2
3. Miguel Cotto



This is a comparison between Shane Mosley and Erik Morales...Which Fighter has the better Ring accomplishments.??

[Castor_Troy]

Im really surprised at this poll

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=353303

Most posters here are high on Shanes victory over Margarito. Data are provided for comparison if i missed someone pls bring it up...

If you look at both fighters Resume, IMO Morales is well ahead. and to note that Morales is constantly inside the TOP 100 fighters of all time from some well respected sites and journalists.

[Castor_Troy]

Please look at the Fighters name and accomplishments and analyze.





4-1 Morales so far.

[Suckmedry]

I'm gonna say Morales.

[Junito-Rulez]

Mosley hands down, he'd have KOed him Prime for prime in a catchweight fight( 132 ).
Erik Morales ducked Naseem and lost his two trilogies.

[Castor_Troy]

Mosley hands down, he'd have KOed him Prime for prime in a catchweight fight( 132 ).
Erik Morales ducked Naseem and lost his two trilogies.

Ducked Nazeem?? and lost 2 trilogies ? because of that Shane is better than him? Shane lost to Winky twice and Vernon twice. Morales also lost to Pac and MAB twice but he was able to beat both of them.

Morales' best wins are Pacquiao and Barrera which is better than Shanes' Oscar and Margarito.

[The_Demon]

sugar shane

[GoogleMe]

Sugar's loss' comes from facing way bigger fighters. (Winky, Vernon) Cotto I don't give a **** ass about.

[miron_lang]

Sugar's loss' comes from facing way bigger fighters. (Winky, Vernon) Cotto I don't give a **** ass about.

Raheem is a natural Lightweight. The fight was @135

Pacquiao is an ATG

[Kilrain]

It's pretty close. Shane is the better fighter. Their resumes are very comparable... I can't help but thinking, who cares? I don't mean to insult the thread but it seems like kind of an irrelevant question. Both have great resumes. Both 3 weight world champions.