How GREAT is Floyd if his 2 best wins are Diego Corrales & Jose Luis Castillo?

[The Hate Giver]

All this im the greatest this & that rant from him & his ***** soldiers yet his best 2 wins are diego corrales & jose luis castillo.

In terms of ATG status how much are those 2 wins worth?

Add in his 3rd & best wins which were ricky hatton & gatti or oscar, seriously how great is floyd's resume?


Out of all the guys he beat, only oscar & juan manuel marquez are true legitimate hall of fame fighters. everybody else are borderline hall of famers.
Even those 2 wins dont equate much for greatness being oscar was 35 & the 6th best 154 pounder when he beat him & as for jmm win, juan drinking piss was more valuable than floyd beating a 36 year old career featherweight at welterweight.


I mean how great really is floyd's resume?



Im just hating... errr i mean saying. im just saying.

[etlux]

All this im the greatest this & that rant from him & his ***** soldiers yet his best 2 wins are diego corrales & jose luis castillo.

In terms of ATG status how much are those 2 wins worth?

Add in his 3rd & best wins which were ricky hatton & gatti or oscar, seriously how great is floyd's resume?


Out of all the guys he beat, only oscar & juan manuel marquez are true legitimate hall of fame fighters. everybody else are borderline hall of famers.
Even those 2 wins dont equate much for greatness being oscar was 35 & the 6th best 154 pounder when he beat him & as for jmm win, juan drinking piss was more valuable than floyd beating a 36 year old career featherweight at welterweight.


I mean how great really is floyd's resume?



Im just hating... errr i mean saying. im just saying.

I don't know. how great is 40 year old De la Hoya and then floyd's sloppy 2nds in a ruined Hatton?

[paulf]

Jose was a ****ing beast when Floyd fought him.

Back in reality though, what are Manny's best wins? Shot Morales? Shot DLH? Overrated Hatton?

It's an easy game to play. and it's pointless.

[Clyde Barrow]

Corrales was looking like a monster at the time PBF took him apart. Castillo was having a strong run at LW, and would resume it after the PBF fights. Can't discredit those wins, or at least not Corrales and Castillo II anyway.

[Reloaded]

Floyd dont have a best 2 wins because thats just bull**** opinion just like P4P nothing but opinion , Floyd has a very solid resume and has outclassed them all , he owned elite fighters thats what makes Floyd special the same as what makes Pac special , the skills Floyd has are ATG without a doubt and you ***ing imbeciles try and focus negatively on trivial bull**** that dont mean a ***en thing , look at the whole picture ya ***en clown ,,,,,, and it aint over yet !

[WarriorSoul]

I don't know. how great is 40 year old De la Hoya and then floyd's sloppy 2nds in a ruined Hatton?

Almost as good as an overblown JMM.

[Earl-Hickey]

I don't know. how great is 40 year old De la Hoya and then floyd's sloppy 2nds in a ruined Hatton?

not as good as Barerra and Morales?

[etlux]

not as good as Barerra and Morales?

excuse me? The only prime Morales Pac fougth, destroyed Pac and humiliated him. Then Morales got owned by Raheem and was clearly shot then Pac beat him.

Barrera 1 was his only good win.

[hugh grant]

PBF is a good boxer. He is probably a top contender for being the second best boxer of the decade behind pac, and thats no easy feat to achieve. Whether he is no2 is another topic though. DLHs of this world are fighting for no2 just like PBF is.

[-GDS-]

The TS is correct. They were plenty of far greater fighters than Corrales and Castillo that Floyd could of fought, but chose not to. Such as...