your top 10 welterweight rankings?

[HandSpeed303]

It really kills me that folks put Floyd #1 still...The man has done nothing at welter that has meant anything...Not to mention the 2 year lay-off...How is he number 1? Cause your a fan of his?

Mosley is the man that beat the man. He should be number 1.

Pac has done his thing at welter. He should be number 2.

Floyd just fought JMM at welter...After a 2 year lay off. He should be 3.

I guess everyone is intitled to their opinions....

I still really don't see how folks can put Floyd number 1 based off body of work alone...I just don't see it.

Also: Remember, he has not fought or beat Mosley yet. So that doesn't count.

[Still Blazin]

1. Mosley

2. Pacquiao

3. Mayweather

[SpinDoctor]

Originally Posted by ny123

collazo has fought the better competition and has proven more then alvarez and brook combined i would have him at 7 i dont know how you could make the argument that aydin senchenko alvarez or brook deserve to be in front of him.

senchenko is the current international WBA World welterweight champion and aydin is the current EBU (European) welterweight chamipion and
WBC International welterweight champion.

[ny123]

1-pac
2-mosley
3-mayeather
4-cotto
5-clottey
6-berto
7-collazo
8-margarito
9-?
10-?

[ny123]

Originally Posted by SpinDoctor

senchenko is the current international WBA World welterweight title champion and aydin is the current EBU (European) welterweight chamipion and
WBC International welterweight champion.

yeah but those belts dont mean **** i dont rank fighters based off of the belts i rank off of skill and resume

[rao007]

Originally Posted by SpinDoctor

Welterweight 147 lbs wins-loss-draw-(kos)

1 Manny Pacquiao Philippines 51-3-2 (38)
2 Floyd Mayweather USA 40-0-0 (25)
3 Shane Mosley USA 46-5-0 (39)
4 Andre Berto USA 25-0-0 (19)
5 Miguel Cotto Puerto Rico 34-2-0 (27)
6 Joshua Clottey Ghana 35-4-0 (20)
7 Selcuk Aydin Germany 19-0-0 (15)
8 Vyacheslav Senchenko Ukraine 30-0-0 (20)
9 Kell Brook England 21-0-0 (14)
10 Saul Alvarez Mexico 31-0-1 (23)

Floyd #2???

[Mujahid Cartel]

Manny Pacquiao
Paul Williams
Shane Mosley
Floyd Mayweather Jr
Miguel Cotto
Antonio Margarito
Joshua Clottey
Andre Berto
Carlos Quintana
Luis Collazo

[HandSpeed303]

Originally Posted by rao007

Floyd #2???

Where should he be sir?

[Jim Jeffries]

Originally Posted by HandSpeed303

Where should he be sir?

Well based on who he's fought in the last 2 years, I can't see how he's ranked at WW at all.

Ability wise he's obviously at the top, but his recent resume is severely lacking.

[HandSpeed303]

Originally Posted by Mujahid Cartel

Manny Pacquiao
Paul Williams
Shane Mosley
Floyd Mayweather Jr
Miguel Cotto
Antonio Margarito
Joshua Clottey
Andre Berto
Carlos Quintana
Luis Collazo

This right here is the point that I was making (this is not directed at the person who wrote this).

For the folks that think Floyd should be number 1, they should have no problem with Paul being number two on this list...No problem at all.