The Official Thread of Inexplicable Officiating

[TRAVI$]

From this day forward all judges that mark ridiculous scorecards shall be listed on the first post of this page and recognised as unworthy to carry out the role in future;


Gale Van Hoy: scored the Diaz-Malignaggi fight 118-110 for Diaz, in a fight which many had Malignaggi winning, and possibly at best for Diaz a draw.

Fellow judges scores were as follows David Sutherland (116-112) and Raul Caiz (115-113)

________________________________

Pierre Benoist: scored the Martinez-Williams encounter 110-119, giving Martinez just one round in an excellent display which could have gone either way.

Fellow judges Julie Lederman & Lynne Carter had respectable scores of 114-114 and 113-115.

________________________________

Alan Davis & Benoit Roussel: scored the Funeka-Guzman fight a draw (114-114) in an extremely one sided fight in which Guzman took a prolonged beating.

Fellow judge Joseph Pasquale recognised this and scored the fight 116-112 Funeka.

[TRAVI$]

Feel free to post any worthy additions in the future, I'll add them all to the main page when I get the chance.

[TRAVI$]

Added judges scores from Malignaggi-Diaz fight, because they were too horrendous to miss.

[mathed]

This year is the year of the payoff!!!!

[Levcon8686]

Funeka-Guzman deserves a mention

[RightCross94]

I've given up complaining about bad judging, it's part of the sport, amateur and professional. It happens and it will always happen.

[TRAVI$]

Funeka-Guzman deserves a mention

It certainly does.

I've given up complaining about bad judging, it's part of the sport, amateur and professional. It happens and it will always happen.

Absolutely, but the individuals getting away with it can atleast get ridiculed by followers of their own sport.