You Be The Judge Robbery or Not

Thread Stealer

Nah. "Robbery" is one of the most overused terms. Castillo took too long to get going and even when he did get going, it wasn't like he was landing with consistency (I dont buy that Compubox *****).

It was a close fight and the decision didn't really bother me, but 5 points was extreme.

It was a pretty entertaining bout too (unlike the rematch).

The Gambler1981

Where is the actual fight~, it was a close and very good fight. It could have gone either way, the main problem with the scoring was the wide margin. I though Floyd held a large edge over the first 6 rounds and then JLC came on to make it close (how the point deductions rounds get scored can be crucial).

Just a close hard fought fight, no robbery.

savorduhflavor

I scored the fight a draw.

The Gambler1981

Quote:

Originally Posted by Thread Stealer

Nah. "Robbery" is one of the most overused terms. Castillo took too long to get going and even when he did get going, it wasn't like he was landing with consistency (I dont buy that Compubox *****).

It was a close fight and the decision didn't really bother me, but 5 points was extreme.

It was a pretty entertaining bout too (unlike the rematch).

Damn U-Verse timed out and you beat me to it.

1000 Left Fist

Quote:

Originally Posted by savorduhflavor

I scored the fight a draw.

i score ur avi "my leading lady for the night, right hand and left hand prepare for battle"

Kevin Jesus

The fight was closer than the judges scored it but Floyd won either way, the important thing that Floyd did was give him the rematch and show he was not a fluke. Fans don't like to mention that he gave Castillo a rematch which shows how confident a fighter is that he did indeed deserved the first close fight that caused the rematch.

¤¤¤

i had mayweather winning the last time i scored the fight. castillo was on top of him most of the time and had some good moments, but i think mayweather was able to slip/block a lot of castillo's punches. i was surprised at the percentages.

AFTER HOURS

jmm will avenge castillo

The Dreamer

@ 5:19 "so I moved up to fight the best lightweight they got out there." I gotta hand it to Floyd for staying true to himself even up to now

1000 Left Fist Banned Join Date: Feb 2009 Posts: 1,165 Rep Power: 0 Points: 235,385.77 Bank: 164,344.27 Total Points: 399,730.04 Donate	You Be The Judge Robbery or Not

Thread Stealer Undisputed Champion Join Date: Sep 2007 Posts: 9,455 Rep Power: 29 Points: 40,981,513.06 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 40,981,513.06 Donate	Nah. "Robbery" is one of the most overused terms. Castillo took too long to get going and even when he did get going, it wasn't like he was landing with consistency (I dont buy that Compubox *****). It was a close fight and the decision didn't really bother me, but 5 points was extreme. It was a pretty entertaining bout too (unlike the rematch).

The Gambler1981 Undisputed Champion Join Date: May 2008 Location: Detroit Age: 32 Posts: 16,668 Rep Power: 44 Points: 600,050,462.87 Bank: 87,589,804,423.98 Total Points: 88,189,854,886.85 Donate $\m/ - Kenny MF Powers$	Where is the actual fight~, it was a close and very good fight. It could have gone either way, the main problem with the scoring was the wide margin. I though Floyd held a large edge over the first 6 rounds and then JLC came on to make it close (how the point deductions rounds get scored can be crucial). Just a close hard fought fight, no robbery.

savorduhflavor Undisputed Champion Join Date: Oct 2008 Posts: 8,227 Rep Power: 27 Points: 21,246,859.25 Bank: 16,794,839,412.73 Total Points: 16,816,086,271.98 Donate	I scored the fight a draw.

Kevin Jesus Banned Join Date: Apr 2009 Location: New York City, New York Posts: 7,922 Rep Power: 21 Points: 80,335.47 Bank: 3,036.94 Total Points: 83,372.41 Donate	The fight was closer than the judges scored it but Floyd won either way, the important thing that Floyd did was give him the rematch and show he was not a fluke. Fans don't like to mention that he gave Castillo a rematch which shows how confident a fighter is that he did indeed deserved the first close fight that caused the rematch.

¤¤¤ No more nothing! Join Date: Feb 2009 Location: U.S. Age: 24 Posts: 904 Rep Power: 6 Points: 601,559.00 Bank: 0.01 Total Points: 601,559.01 Donate	i had mayweather winning the last time i scored the fight. castillo was on top of him most of the time and had some good moments, but i think mayweather was able to slip/block a lot of castillo's punches. i was surprised at the percentages.

AFTER HOURS Paul Hackett Join Date: Sep 2008 Posts: 1,952 Rep Power: 8 Points: 1,000,078,992.02 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 1,000,078,992.02 Donate	jmm will avenge castillo

The Dreamer Undisputed Champion Join Date: May 2009 Age: 29 Posts: 1,090 Rep Power: 9 Points: 2,914,219.04 Bank: 3,740,655.78 Total Points: 6,654,874.82 Donate	@ 5:19 "so I moved up to fight the best lightweight they got out there." I gotta hand it to Floyd for staying true to himself even up to now