If PBF stops JMM then he's back on #1 p4p.

Scoundrel

Believe dat playa

boxasmash

no he aint home boy

MANGLER

He'd be back in the top 5. Not #1 til after he beat Pac.

TRAVI$

If Cotto stops Clottey... He'll be #2
If Floyd stops JMM... He'll be #3

But if Cotto loses, and Floyd dominates Marquez he'll be #2 IMO.

mathed

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scoundrel

Believe dat playa

Please man, get a grip. He is fighting a smaller guy that is older than him, he will get little credit if he demolishes Marquez (which I don't think will happen)

You and I both know that the only way he gets that title back is by beating the man. I don't think anyone will dispute the fact honestly, that Pac is the man right now. Mayweather can say what he wants and so can his moronic father but PBF is standing in line right now and cutting is not allowed.

Burning Desire

Quote:

Originally Posted by TRAVI$

If Cotto stops Clottey... He'll be #2
If Floyd stops JMM... He'll be #3

But if Cotto loses, and Floyd dominates Marquez he'll be #2 IMO.

Miguel Cotto would be borderline top 6 P4P if that i don't see how Miguel Cotto, would be that high considering he isn't even in the top 10 P4P. And even though Joshua Clottey is a good solid fighter, does beating him really warrant such a high placing in the P4P rankings really ?

As for Floyd Mayweather Jr i don't think he is P4P number 1 anymore, even though im a fan of Floyd Mayweather Jr lets be honest his two best wins over Ricky Hatton, ODLH. Don't look that impressive anymore considering Manny Pacquiao destroyed them both easily.

And even if Floyd Mayweather Jr does beat JMM, how does that make him P4P number 1 again ? most people think its a mismatch despite JMM being P4P number 1. And Manny Pacquiao already dropped JMM 4 times in 2 fights, and already beat him at JMM's best weight, yes it was a controversial decision but still a wins a win.

BattlingNelson

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scoundrel

Believe dat playa

No. A win does him nothing other than make a statement that he is back. He might be top 5 though based on past accomplishments.

KO2you

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scoundrel

Believe dat playa

Keyword: "IF" Saying goes "If you wanna be the best you have to beat the best. If you wanna fight the best you have to earn right by beating the rest!!!"

Sin City

he has to work his way back up to the top.. a win over a smaller opponent isn't gonna do it.

TEXSTRO

Quote:

Originally Posted by KO2you

Keyword: "IF" Saying goes "If you wanna be the best you have to beat the best. If you wanna fight the best you have to earn right by beating the rest!!!"

In that case count Mayweather out.....Next

Scoundrel Banned Join Date: Apr 2009 Posts: 30 Rep Power: 0 Points: 8,515.43 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 8,515.43 Donate	If PBF stops JMM then he's back on #1 p4p. Believe dat playa

boxasmash Undisputed Champion Join Date: Aug 2008 Location: United Kingdom Age: 28 Posts: 7,608 Rep Power: 20 Points: 281,002.30 Bank: 46,722,241.03 Total Points: 47,003,243.33 Donate	no he aint home boy

MANGLER Sex Tape Flop Artist Join Date: Feb 2008 Location: In a bunny hole Posts: 38,508 Rep Power: 246 Points: 7,825.04 Bank: 4,204,121,940,185.44 Total Points: 4,204,121,948,010.48 Donate	He'd be back in the top 5. Not #1 til after he beat Pac.

TRAVI$ Banned Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: David Haye's Pleasure Island Age: 23 Posts: 9,259 Rep Power: 0 Points: 133,781.24 Bank: 502,421.29 Total Points: 636,202.53 Donate	If Cotto stops Clottey... He'll be #2 If Floyd stops JMM... He'll be #3 But if Cotto loses, and Floyd dominates Marquez he'll be #2 IMO.

Sin City la mala vida Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: Las Vegas Posts: 29,720 Rep Power: 123 Points: 444,166,040.00 Bank: 14,882,448,580.96 Total Points: 15,326,614,620.96 Donate	he has to work his way back up to the top.. a win over a smaller opponent isn't gonna do it.