Welterweights vs Lightweights

boxaholic

WHich Division is better?
The Welterweight division top 10
1. Paul Williams
2. Antonio Margarito
3. Joshua Clottey
4. Miguel Cotto
5. Shane Mosley
6. Andre Berto
7. Carlos Quintana
8. Luis Collazo
9. Jackson Bonsu
10. Jesus Soto Karass

The Lightweight division top 10
1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Juan Manuel Marquez
3. Nate Campbell
4. Joan Guzman
5. Jose Santa Cruz
6. Joel Cassamayor
7. Juan Diaz
8. Michael Katsidas
9. Lamont Peterson
10. Amir Khan

My answer is the Welterweight division

msagrain

Lightweight.... better fights have been made.

them_apples

I thinl lightweight..but its close

Dan...

I've always preferred WW. Plus PWill, Berto and Cotto are 3 of my favourites. 135 is stacked too though.

savorduhflavor

Lightweight, but just because the tops of the division have fought each other more. I think Welter has more talent.

warp1432

Your lightweight ratings are terrible....

Mr. Fantastic

Quote:

Originally Posted by boxaholic

WHich Division is better?
The Welterweight division top 10
1. Paul Williams
2. Antonio Margarito
3. Joshua Clottey
4. Miguel Cotto
5. Shane Mosley
6. Andre Berto
7. Carlos Quintana
8. Luis Collazo
9. Jackson Bonsu
10. Jesus Soto Karass

I have a feeling you did this on purpose by putting PW at #1 & Cotto at #4. Paperchamp at #6?? Anyways, I would have to say Welter with the fights happening at this moment.

135 may have more names but 147 is putting better fights imo.

Sin City

better fighters in a division doesn't always mean better fights.
is this a who has more talent match up or who has better fights or both?

Sin City

Quote:

Originally Posted by chicano79us

I have a feeling you did this on purpose by putting PW at #1 & Cotto at #4. Paperchamp at #6?? Anyways, I would have to say Welter with the fights happening at this moment.

135 may have more names but 147 is putting better fights imo.

Miguel Cotto is above Paul Williams any day of the week, even with his loss.
Margarito having beat the man should be at the top.
Clottey above Cotto? lolz...

boxaholic

Quote:

Originally Posted by warp1432

Your lightweight ratings are terrible....

And Your rankings would be?

msagrain Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: Ibiza -In Eden or Pacha- Posts: 13,088 Rep Power: 118 Points: 15,246,360.39 Bank: 455,275,844,096.02 Total Points: 455,291,090,456.41 Donate	Lightweight.... better fights have been made.

them_apples Undisputed Champion Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: Ontario, Canada Age: 23 Posts: 6,377 Rep Power: 18 Points: 201,087,486.18 Bank: 1,580,831,841.47 Total Points: 1,781,919,327.65 Donate	I thinl lightweight..but its close

Dan... Fredette About It Join Date: Jun 2008 Location: Brisbane, Australia Age: 28 Posts: 12,346 Rep Power: 34 Points: 1,010,108,166.17 Bank: 2,129,308,816.92 Total Points: 3,139,416,983.09 Donate	I've always preferred WW. Plus PWill, Berto and Cotto are 3 of my favourites. 135 is stacked too though.

savorduhflavor Undisputed Champion Join Date: Oct 2008 Posts: 8,227 Rep Power: 27 Points: 21,246,872.25 Bank: 16,794,839,412.73 Total Points: 16,816,086,284.98 Donate	Lightweight, but just because the tops of the division have fought each other more. I think Welter has more talent.

warp1432 the mailman Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: Illinois Age: 20 Posts: 16,012 Blog Entries: 22 Rep Power: 55 Points: 5,810,796,462.36 Bank: 3,197,440,212,463.26 Total Points: 3,203,251,008,925.62 Donate	Your lightweight ratings are terrible....

Sin City la mala vida Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: Las Vegas Posts: 29,720 Rep Power: 123 Points: 444,177,863.00 Bank: 15,180,097,552.58 Total Points: 15,624,275,415.58 Donate	better fighters in a division doesn't always mean better fights. is this a who has more talent match up or who has better fights or both?