Better Legacy: Calzaghe or Ottke?

[GunStar]

Reid should've won his fights against Calzaghe and Ottke.

Better Legacy, I have to give it to Calzaghe, because Ottke got more gift wins in his career then any other boxer in history.

If you want go by paper, then Ottke wins!

[Mozza]

Originally Posted by $iN

Thank you for letting us know you don't know a single thing about this sport...

And thank you for confirming your status as an arrogant twat who clearly thinks the world of himself.

[porlie]

Originally Posted by Technical_Skill

I havent seen a worse robbery, seriously, there should have been an investigation.

Yeah its mad how it was all just swept under the carpet and forgotten. Thats gotta be the worst decision I've seen in my life time by a long way, its not even as though you could say well I could see how someone would score it for Ottke because theres no way you could.

[Technical_Skill]

Originally Posted by porlie

Yeah its mad how it was all just swept under the carpet and forgotten. Thats gotta be the worst decision I've seen in my life time by a long way, its not even as though you could say well I could see how someone would score it for Ottke because theres no way you could.

Plus reid clearly knocked him down and it got awarded a slip, rediciulous fight, reid said afterwards

"Even Dick Turpin wore a mask"

[Randall_Hopkirk]

Originally Posted by Mozza

Ottke scored 6 KOs in his career, Calzaghe has scored more than 5 times that amount. Says it all really.

That is appalling, a so-called ATG at 168 only has 6 KO's on his record from 30+ wins. wtf?

[SHB]

Originally Posted by GEOFFHAYES

Joe did beat Robin with one arm behind his back

Fixed it .....

I think the Ottke-Reid fight might be the biggest robbery ever.

[Gareth Ivanovic]

I would give it to Calzaghe. Ottke got more gift decisions and Mundine would have beat him, but got caught. Plus he fought Mundine in Mundine's 11th professional fight. If he was so good he would have destroyed somebody with not that much experience as compared to him.

[porlie]

Originally Posted by Technical_Skill

I havent seen a worse robbery, seriously, there should have been an investigation.

Originally Posted by Technical_Skill

Plus reid clearly knocked him down and it got awarded a slip, rediciulous fight, reid said afterwards

"Even Dick Turpin wore a mask"

Yeah its ****ing ridicuolous to even try and compare Ottke with Calzaghe it's a ****ing insult to boxing.

[TheEvilSaint]

Originally Posted by $iN

Joe Calzaghe

Top 5 Wins:
Jeff Lacy
Robin Reid
Chris Eubank
Richie Woodhall
Omar Sheika

-20 straight title defenses.
-Has held the WBO and IBF titles.

Sven Ottke

Top 5 Wins:
Charles Brewer
Glen Johnson
Anthony Mundine
Robin Reid
Byron Mitchell

-22 straight title defenses.
-Won title in his 13th pro fight.
-Held the IBF and WBA titles.
-Retired undefeated.

both of these guys are jokes and so are their "legacies".

[Kayjay's Ghost]

How could you compare Ottke to maybe the best fighter in the sport?