With PBF at 154, Who is Now the Best Welterweight? - Page 3

ThaHorseman

Quote:

Originally Posted by $iN

Mosley hasn't done anything at 147 in years...

Mosley didn't do anything at 147 period. He lost 2 of his 5 fights at 147 and the wins were against nobodies. But he has proven that he can win at 154 since then and for me that counts for more than what the others have done.

King Koyle

Margarito's the top guy IMO.He's paid his due's in the WW division for a long time now.In terms of skills though,that's a different story.I would say Mosley followed by Cotto.

Eno

I think Shane beats everyone on that list. Including my boy Judah.

-Hyperion-

shane Mosley easily.....second would be for me clottey, third would be cotto

norbak1258

Wow I like SSM, but saying that he is the best WW at this moment is a bit confusing to me, last time I checked he has only 1 recent fight at 147. There is more to this than just beating luis collazo. Do you guys think that Collazo would have won a fight againt Clotey, Margarito, Cotto, Zab? I for one won't rate SSM come back to the WW devision until he fights the other top guys, I will say that he looked fantastic on that fight but this is guy that bearly beat/loss to RH, and yes I think Collazo won that fight.

macman

Mosley
Margarito
Cotto
Clottey
Cintron
Judah
Collazo
Baldomir
Williams

Mosley's the only fighter on the list who has completely dominated another top 10 welterweight in Collazo, whom I'd edge over Cintron & have a real chance against Cotto.
Added to his previous top level experience makes him a lock on the top spot.

GunStar

I think Paul Williams will beat all the current welterweight's, yea I know it's too early to say this, but I think he's the real deal and will dominate for a long time.

Technical_Skill

People reading way to much into the Collazo fight, the fight was not as one sided as the scorecards suggest.

Fully Focused Zab Judah beats any of these guys at 147.

Technical_Skill

Quote:

Originally Posted by macman

Mosley
Margarito
Cotto
Clottey
Cintron
Judah
Collazo
Baldomir
Williams

Mosley's the only fighter on the list who has completely dominated another top 10 welterweight in Collazo, whom I'd edge over Cintron & have a real chance against Cotto.
Added to his previous top level experience makes him a lock on the top spot.

Im sorry, i just had to comment on this.

Cintron and Clottey over Judah?

Why are boxing fans so fickle?, no consistency.

Bad Intentions

Zab easily if he can get his **** straight

View Poll Results: Who's the Best Welterweight?
Miguel Cotto	11	14.29%
Shane Mosley	44	57.14%
Antonio Margarito	10	12.99%
Kermit Cintron	0	0%
Paul Williams	3	3.90%
Zab Judah	4	5.19%
Joshua Clottey	2	2.60%
Carlos Baldomir	2	2.60%
Other	1	1.30%
Voters: 77. You may not vote on this poll

King Koyle RIP Chico..we love ya Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: Massachusetts Age: 31 Posts: 2,117 Rep Power: 16 Points: 61,966.56 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 61,966.56 Donate	Margarito's the top guy IMO.He's paid his due's in the WW division for a long time now.In terms of skills though,that's a different story.I would say Mosley followed by Cotto.

Eno Interim Champion Join Date: Aug 2006 Age: 26 Posts: 838 Rep Power: 9 Points: 25,479.26 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 25,479.26 Donate	I think Shane beats everyone on that list. Including my boy Judah.

-Hyperion- The Best And Fastest Ride Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: Mexico city Age: 22 Posts: 17,012 Rep Power: 100 Points: 25,707,090.23 Bank: 4,423,748,059,792.73 Total Points: 4,423,773,766,882.97 Donate	shane Mosley easily.....second would be for me clottey, third would be cotto

macman Interim Champion Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: Sydney Posts: 815 Rep Power: 10 Points: 333,151.35 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 333,151.35 Donate	Mosley Margarito Cotto Clottey Cintron Judah Collazo Baldomir Williams Mosley's the only fighter on the list who has completely dominated another top 10 welterweight in Collazo, whom I'd edge over Cintron & have a real chance against Cotto. Added to his previous top level experience makes him a lock on the top spot.

GunStar Banned Join Date: Oct 2005 Location: New York Age: 14 Posts: 11,918 Rep Power: 0 Points: 168,127.53 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 168,127.53 Donate	I think Paul Williams will beat all the current welterweight's, yea I know it's too early to say this, but I think he's the real deal and will dominate for a long time.

Technical_Skill Into The Deep Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: In My Own Mind Posts: 6,415 Rep Power: 20 Points: 53,690.03 Bank: 348,532.02 Total Points: 402,222.05 Donate	People reading way to much into the Collazo fight, the fight was not as one sided as the scorecards suggest. Fully Focused Zab Judah beats any of these guys at 147.

Bad Intentions Undisputed Champion Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: Pennsylvania Age: 28 Posts: 1,359 Rep Power: 11 Points: 108,302.04 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 108,302.04 Donate	Zab easily if he can get his **** straight