Joe Calzaghe vs James Toney at 168 who wins?

[KingHippo]

Joe was well past it when he schooled a near prime Roy remember that.

Calzaghe (36 years old 45-0) was well past it but Roy Jones (39 years old 52-4) was near prime.

Gotta love the low IQ action

[A.K]

James easily, and a lot of people don't know James was called in on short notice for Roy when he was 40 pounds over the weight limit and had 3 weeks to train for the fight. I feel it would of been a classic if James had his full camp.

[A.K]

Joe was well past it when he schooled a near prime Roy remember that.

Kys ydksab

[CHOWWOKKA]

James Toney sodomizes Calzaghe

[puro dinamita]

James Toney would be too much for a feather fisted joe. Toney by K.O

[richardt]

Joe was well past it when he schooled a near prime Roy remember that.

Get real! Jones was already shot as a fighter and had two concussive KO losses when he faced Cal who was closer to his prime. Anyone with boxing knowledge knows this.

[Prince Madison]

two of my favourites, but calzaghe was the better fighter. Cocaine joe by wide UD.

[bojangles1987]

Calzaghe by decision, he wins around 8 rounds.

[bojangles1987]

James easily, and a lot of people don't know James was called in on short notice for Roy when he was 40 pounds over the weight limit and had 3 weeks to train for the fight. I feel it would of been a classic if James had his full camp.

Get real, he was overweight going into every fight. Roy embarrassed Toney because Roy was just that much better.

Whenever Toney looked like ass (often) people always want to blame the weight. Same **** happened no matter what division he was in.

[gauze]

why is this a thread? toney by knockout.