Would you consider Floyd an ATG if he defeated Martinez at 160 to become MW champion?

[mathed]

I already consider Mayweather as one of the best boxing has ever seen. That being said, I also believe, to be as talented as he is, Floyd doesn't challenge himself like all-time greats in the past have (see Sugar Ray Robinson). For those who don't consider Floyd an ATG, would moving up in weight and defeating Sergio Martinez to become the middleweight champion of the world change your opinion?

Where does Sergio fall if he beats Floyd at 160?

[DeadLikeMe]

If he went to 160 and took Sergio's lineal strap, it would give him claim to greatest of this era...as it stands now he, BHop, Roy, kinda Evander and obviously Manny all have good claims to higher rankings...that would elevate Floyd above them all easily IMO

[illmaticfighter]

Just like i said. That's the p4p ranking from September 21, 2009.
Mosley fought Mayweather in May 2010 after 14 months without boxing. He wasn't a top 10 p4p at the time.

http://www.examiner.com/article/boxi...ling-has-begun

sorry it's true