Assuming floyd beats shane, would you give him more credit than cotto?

[Biolink]

Probably around the same.

I don't expect Mosley to have dropped off as much in the 2 years as Cotto has.

[dibzvincent143]

Not more or less credit. The same credit. If Floyd beats Shane it will be one of the best wins of his career. No one should discredit it, just like no one should discredit Cotto's win over Shane.

the question is who wll you give more credit. im not asking who among them dont deserve a credit for a win against ssm.

[dibzvincent143]

i didnt no 17 year olds could gamble

a friendly gamble though, only with my friends, schoolmates or relatives or any boxing fan who would agree.

[murmagic]

they deserve equal credit tbh, theres many aguments who deseves more,

-Some people believe Shane beat cotto.
-Styles make fights
-Shanes coming off a long layoff but one of the biggest wins of his career
-people will always find a way to discredit floyd

but imo it depends on how the fight pans out...

[PAKYO]

If floyd wins it pittypatting Shane via decision, nope.
If floyd wins by KO, yeah but then....Shane is almost 40. Shane is old.