Better resume: Casamayor or Tarver?

[Fox McCloud]

Casamayor
Wins - Corrales, Corrales, Katsidis, Campbell, Santa Cruz (officially)
Losses - Castillo, Freitas, Marquez, Corrales

Tarver
Wins - Reggie Johnson, Glen Johnson, Jones, Jones, Griffin, Woods, Harding
Losses - Jones, Harding, Glen Johnson, Hopkins, Dawson, Dawson

[-Boxzilla-]

campbell was a pretty solid win for casa as well ...

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Casamayor and Casamayor is te better fighter too!!!!

[Fox McCloud]

campbell was a pretty solid win for casa as well ...

You've successfully made me feel like a dip****... I feel very foolish for leaving that one out.

[Walt Liquor]

I'm going to say Tarver's by a c hair. Those wins over Roy are big, so is casa's give v Santa cruz. I think casa was ducked a lot in his career and could have had a better resume.

[RingTech01]

casamayor...

[Doctor_Tenma]

Casamayor only has 2 loses in my opinion, Marquez and Santa Cruz (Due to not taking him serious).

Other then that, he got robbed in the Corrales rematch, against JLC and Freitas. Gonna go with Casamayor.

[Fox McCloud]

I'm going to say Tarver's by a c hair. Those wins over Roy are big, so is casa's give v Santa cruz. I think casa was ducked a lot in his career and could have had a better resume.

I don't know about all that, that he ducked people...

Fighting Freitas, Corrales three times and Castillo doesn't leave a ton of room for people he ducked. If anything, the only person he didn't get in the ring with that he should have was Mayweather...

I think it's Tarver's underrated wins, against people like Reggie Johnson, Woods and Griffin that boost his resume above Casamayor's... those wins are bigger than people make them out to be. Plus, his two performances against Glen Johnson were among the most underrated in the sport that I can remember.

[Kevin Jesus]

Even though i dislike him for what he did to my idol, Antonio Tarver has a better resume than Casamayor.

[Walt Liquor]

I don't know about all that, that he ducked people...

Fighting Freitas, Corrales three times and Castillo doesn't leave a ton of room for people he ducked. If anything, the only person he didn't get in the ring with that he should have was Mayweather...

I think it's Tarver's underrated wins, against people like Reggie Johnson, Woods and Griffin that boost his resume above Casamayor's... those wins are bigger than people make them out to be. Plus, his two performances against Glen Johnson were among the most underrated in the sport that I can remember.

Casa didn't duck. He was ducked.

See keV, we agree-
Again!