does the winner of thurman - porter crown a new welterweight king?

[GOT BEEF?]

interesting replies...

[jose.sooto]

How in the world does Pac vs Bradley III crown the new 147 king?

Keith Thurman vs Shawn Porter is a way better matchup btw two prime full fledged welterweights. Porter is coming off a great W over Broner and Thurman is carrying the 0.

Tim Bradle's last three fights have been against fckin bum bum rios, jesse vergas and diego chaves....can someone care to explain how that schedule equals to being an elite 147er?

Pac is coming of a loss to Floyd and a fight against fckin chris algiero

Not to mention Pac Bradley III is a worthless fight, the winner should not be crowned new 147 king, that title belongs to the winner of Thurman-Porter.

[R_Walken]

The winner of Pac / Bradley is clearly in the drivers seat but they have no long term upside. Manny wins he might retire Bradley wins who's left on the TR HBO side besides Crawford which they stated they won't fight each other is left that is any good.

Brooks on his own island right now ,got the belt now fighting cans overseas so until Spence is the mandatory we might not find out how good he actually is or face a legit threat .

The winner of Porter / Thurman have a win over a top 5 WW and will have options in Garcia, Khan, Spence ( in the future ) ,even stay busy fights could be Peterson,Guerrero, Aaron Marinez / Vasquez winner , Berto , Algieri

Although The winner of Porter/Thurman won't be the #1 WW now,they'll probably be in the future.

[jqSide]

How in the world does Pac vs Bradley III crown the new 147 king?

Keith Thurman vs Shawn Porter is a way better matchup btw two prime full fledged welterweights. Porter is coming off a great W over Broner and Thurman is carrying the 0.

Tim Bradle's last three fights have been against fckin bum bum rios, jesse vergas and diego chaves....can someone care to explain how that schedule equals to being an elite 147er?

Pac is coming of a loss to Floyd and a fight against fckin chris algiero

Not to mention Pac Bradley III is a worthless fight, the winner should not be crowned new 147 king, that title belongs to the winner of Thurman-Porter.

Why don't you just state your case without crying and whining? This is forum where things are discussed. Let's start with Thurman. Explain why One Time gets to be crowned the new WW king after beating Porter. Then go to Porter next. You might even convince a lot of folks here. Crying like a ******ed 5 year old will get you nowhere.

[Daud]

It is a very solid win and if one of them wins very impressively, it will boost their p4p rankings and value. But it is not like an unification bout or anything.