Greatest Southpaw in Boxing History: Whitaker, Hagler, or manny

[GrandpaBernard]

Now that manny's career is over who was the greatest lefty?

[WarVeteranO01]

Now that manny's career is over who was the greatest lefty?

1. Hagler
2. Whittaker
3. Manny

And this is only based on size because all three were beast and great at what they did. Hagler wouldve gotten way more credit if the SRL fight went his way. Its a shame he as robbed. I also think Hagler would make GGG cry.

[NearHypnos]

I'd go with the same order as above from those three names.

Hagler cuz Im biased...

Pernell cuz he'd have beaten Manny

And Manny at number 3 by default

[IMDAZED]

Take this to the history section because you're going to get a lot of dumb, uninformed answers on here.

[Larry the boss]

Id honestly have to rank Manny over both of them

[NearHypnos]

Inb4 a Calzaghe fan comes in all butt hurt

[Larry the boss]

I'd go with the same order as above from those three names.

Hagler cuz Im biased...

Pernell cuz he'd have beaten Manny

And Manny at number 3 by default

I agree Whitaker would beat Manny but Manny did accomplish more and has the better resume imo

[The Big Dunn]

Hagler
Sweet Pea
Manny

[IMDAZED]

I agree Whitaker would beat Manny but Manny did accomplish more and has the better resume imo

It's a toss-up between the two. Whitaker's got some great names on his resume and didn't definitively lose until the Tito bout. But Pacquiao holds his own. Hagler comes in third.

[Skip Bayless]

in terms of acomplishments: pac>hagler>pernell
in terms of skill/ability: pernell>pac>hagler

and no hagler wasnt robbed by srl, he got slapped to a ud