Ranked higher alltime Oscar or Jmm

[Jc8804]

Who is ranked higher alltime in your opinion

Thoughts

[DeadLikeMe]

Oscar's "bad" fights are better than most of the "good" fights on JMM's resume.

[face untouched]

Who cares they're both victims of Floyd

[Jc8804]

Keep floyd out the conversation unless its about the fights with
These two specifically regarding their alltime status.
.

[Jc8804]

Oscar won some big fights

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Good question

answer: oscar....

jmm has some great wins but oscar's resume is crazy

molina
leija
ruelas
genaro
chavez twice
pernell
ike
vargas
camacho
gatti
castello
mayorga
sturm
carr
paez

plus 2 controversial fights vs tito and shane rematch

plus shane 1, floyd, hopkins, floyd and manny


oscar performed much better vs floyd
jmm performed much better vs manny

but jmm just doesnt have enough depth to compare to oscar,,,

Oscar was literally involved in super fights every year for a decade
96-chavez
97-pernell
98- chavez 2,,, not exactly a superfight, but big money fight
99- ike and tito
00- shane
01- gatti,- not a superfight, but big money fight
02- vargas
03- shane rematch
04-hopkins
05- inactive
06- mayorga- not a superfight, but big fight
07- floyd
08- manny