The Unpopular Opinion thread.

[jabsRstiff]

I don't think Ketchel, Walker or Hopkins are greater.

That's fine.

Their resumes are all comparable, but I think he'd lose to all 3, and would have lost to Cerdan if Cerdan wasn't injured.

[jabsRstiff]

Roy Jones woulda scorched Jake, IMO.

[RubenSonny]

That's fine.

Their resumes are all comparable, but I think he'd lose to all 3, and would have lost to Cerdan if Cerdan wasn't injured.

I think Steele would beat him too, I just think he's an underrated fighter - mostly in terms of resume, that's just me though I don't have a solid list middleweight ranking of my own.

[The Surgeon]

Here's one - Ricky Hatton was a damn good 140lb Fighter!

Or Ike Ibeabuchi would have slaughtered the Klitchko bro's

And at one point Joan Guzman could have spanked Manny Pac

[The Surgeon]

Roy Jones woulda scorched Jake, IMO.

100% Agreed

[kendom]

Here are mine

Roy Jones is overrated

Even if a sixties version of Ali fought Frazier he would have still had one loss in a trilogy.

Fight of the century was the best fight of the Ali Frazier trilogy and the thrilla in manila is overrated

Foreman's slugfest with Lyle is overrated, much of the excitement came from the multiple knockdowns instead of the pace of the fight.

[The Smash]

I thought SRL won the first fight with Duran.

[studentofthegam]

I hate I'm late for this one. Here goes nothing.

Mayweather is the best boxer I've had the pleasure of watching.

Duran, though he should be highly rated, is overrated to the point of invincibility.

I also believe that you cant rank fighters in your top 10 that you cant see fights of.

Mike Tyson isnt an all time great.

Larry Holmes is a top 3 HW all-time.

[studentofthegam]

I thought SRL won the first fight with Duran.

Drunk

I don't think Ketchel, Walker or Hopkins are greater.

I think Hopkins takes a big hit for his resume which aint that bad. His accolades far exceed anybody's on the list except maybe Monzon. He deserves to be top 5 to me.

[StarshipTrooper]

Mayweather is the best boxer I've had the pleasure of watching.

Mike Tyson isnt an all time great.

Drunk :shootsself: