Will the Ring Magazine rank Floyd P4P Number 1?

[And Still]

I think they will fellas. Rightfully so IMO.

The gap will narrow BIG TIME. Pac will probably retain the #1 spot, because they have traditionally not replaced guys at the top without a loss.

But Floyd will replace Pac on many, many other top lists. For example, the Yahoo! list.

[T.Horton]

They should, but they do stupid stuff like making Manny the top WW over Mosley. Don't count on them to do the right thing.

please justify this. Pacquiao had just beaten Cotto who had beaten Shane. Yea, Shane beat up Margarito who knocked out Cotto but the key here is how they both did against the former number one welter - cotto.

[T.Horton]

The gap will narrow BIG TIME. Pac will probably retain the #1 spot, because they have traditionally not replaced guys at the top without a loss.

But Floyd will replace Pac on many, many other top lists. For example, the Yahoo! list.

this is the answer right here.

[23|1|26|1|1]

I think they will. I honestly have it a tie now between Floyd and Manny.

[swizz]

please justify this. Pacquiao had just beaten Cotto who had beaten Shane. Yea, Shane beat up Margarito who knocked out Cotto but the key here is how they both did against the former number one welter - cotto.

floyd dominated shane not just beaT him and your logic is stupid is not who beat who its style that makes a fight

[Sweet Jesus]

They should, but they won't.

[Sweet Jesus]

please justify this. Pacquiao had just beaten Cotto who had beaten Shane. Yea, Shane beat up Margarito who knocked out Cotto but the key here is how they both did against the former number one welter - cotto.

Cotto was 1 1/2 years removed from being the top WW when Pac fought him.

[And Still]

this is the answer right here.

I went to Max Boxing this morning, and they were saying this:

"...anyone still claiming that Pacquiao is p4p best needs to get their head checked..."

[spidey17]

The question is "Should they rank Floyd P4P Number 1?"

In my honest opinion they shouldnt. Pacman didnt do anything wrong in his last fight that would justify him being droped from his perch.

[the_ilest]

I went to Max Boxing this morning, and they were saying this:

"...anyone still claiming that Pacquiao is p4p best needs to get their head checked..."

yeah no doubt about that. Floyd proved is is a mad genious in the ring.