Grand Theft Auto IV or Red Dead Redemption?

[bravestone]

vs

[Russian Crushin]

Simply hated #4, I hope 5 is better. I'm not the biggest fan of red dead but its a decent game with a new premise

[San Iker]

Red dead. Not even close.

GTA IV was so boring. Got to like 60% and stopped.

Red Dead is the best game made in this sorry ass generation.

[bravestone]

Red Dead was so amazing though how can anyone not have fun?

[Barn]

GTA IV easily.

[SplitSecond]

red dead is a great great game, until you clear it, then it quickly gets boring

gta iv sucks from the beggining, and continues to suck to the ending

[Phenom]

only the parts in Mexico were exceptional about Red Dead other then that it was just a decent game nothing special GTA IV + DLC is easily better

[Da Machine]

Could never get into red dead. Don't know why. It was a decent game.

[squealpiggy]

Red Dead is great. GTA IV was showing its age.

[TheNegation]

RDD for sure. GTA4 was good but it was way too short.

RDD was a great game with shytloads of side missions and cool mini-games. Only thing I hated was you couldn't switch back to John after you finished story mode. You were stuck with his annoying ass kid.