Better Resume Vitali Klitschko or Nikolai Valuev?

[Simurgh]

I was expecting this to be jab's thread

Anyway... it's clearly Valuev.. he is top3 ATG no doubt.

[GRboxing]

Being considered an ATG at Cruiserweight - especially during that time - is essentially the equivalent of being one of the smartest kids in remedial class. Usually I'd say that all a guy can do is beat the best available competition, but Gomez never even did that. Without even bothering to look up the ratings of that time, I'd gather that he fought about two guys that were actually actually rated during that time.

Haha that made LOL

[beez721]

Discuss and vote boxing heads.

Valuev:

Evander Holyfield
Sergey Liakhovic
John Ruiz
Jean Bergeron
Larry Donald
Jameel McCline

Vitali:

Corrie Sanders
Sam Peter
Adamek
Kirk Johnson
Chris Arreola
Larry Donald

valuev got a few gift wins with holyfield,,,donald and ruiz

[New England]

jab, now i know it's you.

[Jam Jars]

Valuev definitely has the better names.

[Derranged]

Valuev is one of the worst heavyweight title holders of all time. He didn't even win it legitimately, he got a gift decision against Donald which got him the title shot and another gift decision against Ruiz to win it.

Hey Jab, did Vitali rape your father in a Ukrainian prison or something?

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Vitali,,,,, I dont want to go into all the details because i think this is a nonsense thread,,


but its equal to asking: better resume haye or holyfield or zab or forrest

[beez721]

Vitali,,,,, I dont want to go into all the details because i think this is a nonsense thread,,


but its equal to asking: better resume haye or holyfield or zab or forrest

yea its a no brainer altho vitalis resume is relatively weak. at least he didnt get gift decisions unlike valuev who got a slew of them

[Black Barty]

Discuss and vote boxing heads.

Valuev:

Evander Holyfield
Sergey Liakhovic
John Ruiz
Jean Bergeron
Larry Donald
Jameel McCline

Vitali:

Corrie Sanders
Sam Peter
Adamek
Kirk Johnson
Chris Arreola
Larry Donald

Is this a joke thread?

If you had actually seen the fights you listed, you would know that Valuev's "wins" over Donald, Ruiz and Holyfield were all gift decisions, and the McCline "KO" was a fluke injury stoppage.

Vitali's resume isn't world beating by any measure but comparing it to Valuev's is laughable.

[Russian Crushin]

Valuev is one of the worst champs ever. Actually lost his 4 biggest fights and never should have even been a "champ"