Better Legacy: Calzaghe or Ottke?

[!! $iN]

Joe Calzaghe

Top 5 Wins:
Jeff Lacy
Robin Reid
Chris Eubank
Richie Woodhall
Omar Sheika

-20 straight title defenses.
-Has held the WBO and IBF titles.

Sven Ottke

Top 5 Wins:
Charles Brewer
Glen Johnson
Anthony Mundine
Robin Reid
Byron Mitchell

-22 straight title defenses.
-Won title in his 13th pro fight.
-Held the IBF and WBA titles.
-Retired undefeated.

[GEOFFHAYES]

Brewer and Mitchell were robbed against Ottke - Joe beat them up

[Technical_Skill]

Joe Calzaghe

Top 5 Wins:
Jeff Lacy
Robin Reid
Chris Eubank
Richie Woodhall
Omar Sheika

-20 straight title defenses.
-Has held the WBO and IBF titles.

Sven Ottke

Top 5 Wins:
Charles Brewer
Glen Johnson
Anthony Mundine
Robin Reid
Byron Mitchell

-22 straight title defenses.
-Won title in his 13th pro fight.
-Held the IBF and WBA titles.
-Retired undefeated.

On PAPER, it might be ottke.

Paper doesnt account for the fact his fights were fixed.

[porlie]

Calzaghe because Ottkes win against Reid cant really be counted because Reid was robbed blind.

[Mozza]

Ottke scored 6 KOs in his career, Calzaghe has scored more than 5 times that amount. Says it all really.

[!! $iN]

Brewer and Mitchell were robbed against Ottke - Joe beat them up

Ottke got to them first. If robberies don't count then you have to take away Calzaghe's win against Reid, which is considered the best of his career...

[Technical_Skill]

Ottkes win against Reid cant really be counted because Reid was robbed blind.

I havent seen a worse robbery, seriously, there should have been an investigation.

[GEOFFHAYES]

Ottke got to them first. If robberies don't count then you have to take away Calzaghe's win against Reid, which is considered the best of his career...

Joe could beat Robin with one arm behind his back

[!! $iN]

Ottke scored 6 KOs in his career, Calzaghe has scored more than 5 times that amount. Says it all really.

Thank you for letting us know you don't know a single thing about this sport...

[porlie]

Reid and Calzaghe was very close but Calzaghe just pipped it IMO. Reid against Ottke was a ****ing blatant robbery though so it's hardly comparable.