Does James Toney Have Better WINS Than Roy Jones Jr?

[Perfect Plex]

While Roy is the greater fighter, does James have the better resume of WINS?

Toney Stand Out Wins
-Michael Nunn: 36-0 Ranked in the top 3 P4P & #1 Middleweight.
-24-0 Tim Littles #6 Ranked Middleweight
-1992 Mike McCallum who was 11-0-1 in his 12 fights.
-1993 Iran Barkley (11 Months earlier had KO'd Hearns for WBA 175lb Title)
-31-0 Vassiliy Jirov #1 ranked Cruiserweight in the world
-2003 38-6 Evander Holyfield

Yes or No?

[CarlosG815]

I think the answer is Roy Jones Jr.

[dan_cov]

No & I don't think it's particularly that close.

[SCtrojansbaby]

While Roy is the greater fighter, does James have the better resume of WINS?

Toney Stand Out Wins
-Michael Nunn: 36-0 Ranked in the top 3 P4P & #1 Middleweight.
-24-0 Tim Littles #6 Ranked Middleweight
-1992 Mike McCallum who was 11-0-1 in his 12 fights.
-1993 Iran Barkley (11 Months earlier had KO'd Hearns for WBA 175lb Title)
-31-0 Vassiliy Jirov #1 ranked Cruiserweight in the world
-2003 38-6 Evander Holyfield

Yes or No?

Toney's win over Williams>>>>>>win over Barkley

1. Toney
2. Hopkins
3. Hill
4. Ruiz
5. Castro
6. Malinga or a number of other guys

Also just look at there respective fights against Johnson and Sosa

[nachorjj]

no, James have better resume. I think that he go to beat Lebedev

[IronDanHamza]

I think Toney's wins over McCallum and Nunn are great stand out wins.

But I don't think they are as good as Roy's stand out wins over Hopkins and Toney.

[Pastrano]

I think Toney's wins over McCallum and Nunn are great stand out wins.

But I don't think they are as good as Roy's stand out wins over Hopkins and Toney.

Toney's wins are worth gold, those over McCallum and Nunn. Hopkins was not yet fully developed as a fighter back then and Toney was as we know, drained. I think Roy's best win was actually against Montell Griffin. Nobody had even beaten Griffin until then and he destroyed him in 1 round. After that I rank the Tarver win, Tarver was at his best at the time.

[SCtrojansbaby]

Toney's wins are worth gold, those over McCallum and Nunn. Hopkins was not yet fully developed as a fighter back then and Toney was as we know, drained. I think Roy's best win was actually against Montell Griffin. Nobody had even beaten Griffin until then and he destroyed him in 1 round. After that I rank the Tarver win, Tarver was at his best at the time.

lol at Montell Griffin.

[wmute]

Jones beat Hopkins and Toney. That's the beginning at the end of it.

Toney is my personal favorite out of the 3 above. Toney-McCallum 1 is probably my all time favorite fight, but that does not change the fact that Jones has those two wins on his resume, and Toney has nothing to match them.

[bojangles1987]

I wouldn't say so.