Originally posted by egreezy
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Should Cotto still be #8 P4P?
Collapse
-
Not just resume is it though. No one can beat Hatton in his division, he's Ring champ, and he just beat the #2 guy. Can Cotto say that? No.
Comment
-
-
-
-
Originally posted by KrisSilver View PostNot just resume is it though. No one can beat Hatton in his division, he's Ring champ, and he just beat the #2 guy. Can Cotto say that? No.
Comment
-
Originally posted by danc1984 View PostI don't like Hatton a great deal but I agree with you Chunk, it doesn't. Who is that in the av?
Originally posted by larryx View Postcottos resume>hattons resume
Whereas Cotto's losses to Margarito but he stays in the top 10 even though Margarito wasn't even in the top 10 when he beat Cotto if i recall?
I think that's bull**** to be honest. Hatton belongs in the top 10.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Chunk View PostSammy Braddy.
I don't think that even comes into the argument though. I agree that Cotto has a better resume then Hatton, but Hatton's one loss came against P4P#1 Mayweather and he's dropped out of the top 10 completely.
Whereas Cotto's losses to Margarito but he stays in the top 10 even though Margarito wasn't even in the top 10 when he beat Cotto if i recall?
I think that's bull**** to be honest. Hatton belongs in the top 10.
Comment
-
Originally posted by danc1984 View PostThat is not analysing it from a p4p perspective though. According to your criteria for ranking fighters p4p those who are in weak divisions have a massive advantage. 140 in absolutely awful right now, potentially the worst division in boxing. Hatton gets limited credit from me for being the best in it.
If they were and in WW, it would be even more impressive and credit worthy, I agree. Perhaps not quite to the extent as you or some as I tend to think nearly half the top 10 p4p being Welterweights is a little over the top. But hey, I do agree.
Comment
-
First of all, props to everyone for no hating. It's rare that a thread with Cotto,Marg,PWill, or PBF as the main topic doesn't breed hate but everyone has said legitimate, unbiased arguments.
I'm with dancr in saying I'm not sure where I think he belongs. P4P is hard to develop a criteria for. Do I think, even with the Margo loss, that he's a top 10 fighter in the world? Yea, I do. So if that's what we're going by than I'd say latter half of top 10 is where he belongs.
But everyone saying guys like Vic have had better years, and are currently doing better have good points too.
It's definitely debatable.
Comment
Comment