Peyton Manning's legacy: Choker or Champion?

[DeadLikeMe]

Puts up 8 points in the Super Bowl with the highest scoring offense in NFL history. Peyton has full control of the offense. Most losses in playoff history and a losing record in the playoffs. More interceptions than touchdowns in all 3 Super Bowls.

[Mr Ehrmantraut]

Seattle would still have won by a landslide with this seasons Matt Schaub as quarterback.

[~AK49~]

Neither. It is a team game, and Seattle was simply the better team in every facet. Not a choker, as he just faced an atg defense, but obviously not a champion aswell.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

OmaHIKE!

[BUNGALOWS]

Football is a team game. His receivers were getting suffocated at the line, and Peyton's not a mobile quarterback.

That's why smart money was on Seattle. When option 1-4 is taken away from you, and you're not a running QB, you turn average.

It's as simple as that. Tom Brady wouldn't have done any better.

And Eli would have soiled his pants.

[Rip Chudd]

Football is a team game. His receivers were getting suffocated at the line, and Peyton's not a mobile quarterback.

That's why smart money was on Seattle. When option 1-4 is taken away from you, and you're not a running QB, you turn average.

It's as simple as that. Tom Brady wouldn't have done any better.

And Eli would have soiled his pants.

This^^^^^^^^^^^^

[J The UnBiased]

It was an embarrassing performance by the team. Peyton will go down as 1 of the best ever. But that whole better than Tom Brady talk, potential to be better than Joe Montana, that shit is dead, over, it's a wrap.

[BostonGuy]

Puts up 8 points in the Super Bowl with the highest scoring offense in NFL history. Peyton has full control of the offense. Most losses in playoff history and a losing record in the playoffs. More interceptions than touchdowns in all 3 Super Bowls.

I thought he only went to the Super Bowl twice?

[ИATAS]

No QB could have beat Seattle's defense yesterday. What you witnessed was true greatness. Everyone was focusing on Manning and the #1 offense when they should have been focusing on the #1 defense. As the saying goes, great defense wins championships.

[BUNGALOWS]

No QB could have beat Seattle's defense yesterday. What you witnessed was true greatness. Everyone was focusing on Manning and the #1 offense when they should have been focusing on the #1 defense. As the saying goes, great defense wins championships.

Dude, the Seahwaks defense was literally the fastest defense I've seen in like 5-10 years. Maybe ever.

They're SO FAST.

It looked like a College team going up against a JV high school team.