Where does a win over Maidana rank on Floyds resume?

[boxfan1983]

Top 3, 5, 10??? How do you base your opinion, on Floyds (supposed) lack of superior opposition "or" Maidanas being a truly legitimate threat???

[Ca$trO]

In the vicinity of Baldomair and Gatti (RIP)

[-PBP-]

Definitely not top 10.

Corralles
Castillo 1
Castillo II
Hatton
Cotto
Canelo
Judah
Hernandez
Mosley
De La Hoya

All better wins than Maidana.

[Holywarrior]

In the vicinity of Baldomair and Gatti (RIP)

This seems fair. Above Gatti for me, probably not top 10 though. Mayweather's resume is deep as far as top 10 wins go

Hatton
Chavez
Canelo
Cotto
Manfredy
Hernandez
Delahoya
Mosley
Marquez
Corrales
Castillo

[icebergisonfire]

Not particularly high because he's not particularly good.

[Divine Hammer]

i'd say top 3 just behind canelo. for me his top 3 best wins are:

1. corrales
2. canelo
3. maidana (if he wins)

[12TRIBEsRiSe]

It would be a good win vs a champ in the top 5 of his weight class i dont know where id rate the win in his competition tho

[NEETzsche]

it's a solid title defence, not really a jewel in his crown

[fundicao]

Top 5

Cotto
Canelo
De la hoya
Maidana
Corrales

[Public_Enemy]

It's not top 10. It's just a solid/good win. If Floyd scores a KO, that would be noteworthy though (doubt it happens though).