Mayweather or Mosley: Who is the More Accomplished Fighter?

[Ether]

PBF FTW lolz.

[Technical_Skill]

Floyd, and easily.

His resume far exceeds Shane's.

Bro, im a fan of PBF too, but there is no way his resume 'Far' exceeds Shane's

how can it when shane has fought better fighters?

Prime De La Hoya Twice

Prime Winky Wright Twice

Prime Vernnon Forrest twice (dont tell me forrest wasnt good, he was undefeated, the 1st man to be moesly and on the p4p list)

Fernando Vargas Twice

You can't reason PBF's resume is MUCH better than Shane's, if at all.

[Parody]

Shane Mosley

Top 5 Wins:

Philip Holiday
John John Molina
James Leija
Oscar de la Hoya (twice)
Fernando Vargas (twice).

Career Accomplishments:

3 division champion (135, 147, and 154)
10 title defenses at lightweight
Lineal champion at 147 and 154
Considered #1 P4P from mid-2000 until early 2002

Other Notes:

Lost twice each to Winky Wright and Vernon Forrest
His second win over De la Hoya is highly controversial

Floyd Mayweather

Top 5 Wins:

Genaro Hernandez
Diego Corrales
Jesus Chavez
Jose Luis Castillo (twice)
Zab Judah

Career Accomplishments:

4 division champion (130-147)
9 title defenses at 130
Lineal Champion at 130 and 147
Has been considered #1 P4P since mid-2005

Other Notes:
His first win against Jose Luis Castillo is controversial
Some consider Manny Pacquiao as the current #1 P4P

Floyd was the linear champ at 135 as well. It was just at 140 he was'nt, but 130,135, and 147 Mayweather was the linear champion.

[GunStar]

Bro, im a fan of PBF too, but there is no way his resume 'Far' exceeds Shane's

how can it when shane has fought better fighters?

Prime De La Hoya Twice

Prime Winky Wright Twice

Prime Vernnon Forrest twice (dont tell me forrest wasnt good, he was undefeated, the 1st man to be moesly and on the p4p list)

Fernando Vargas Twice

You can't reason PBF's resume is MUCH better than Shane's, if at all.

He lost 4 of those fights, Vargas was washed up and many thought Oscar won the second fight.

This is a no brainer, PBF easily exceeds Mosley in resume, in skills and he's still undefeated!

[Technical_Skill]

He lost 4 of those fights, Vargas was washed up and many thought Oscar won the second fight.

This is a no brainer, PBF easily exceeds Mosley in resume, in skills and he's still undefeated!

It's not a no brainer, if Floyd stepped up to 154 to fight Winky and Vargas twice, prime De la Hoya twice you dont think there is any chance he could lose?

Come on man, i love PBF and his skills, but Moesly fought better opposition, Forrest was P4P at the time and a serious fighter before Mayorga got to him, and i think he beat Mayorga in the rematch anyway, i belive the cards were very close.

[GunStar]

It's not a no brainer, if Floyd stepped up to 154 to fight Winky and Vargas twice, prime De la Hoya twice you dont think there is any chance he could lose?

Come on man, i love PBF and his skills, but Moesly fought better opposition, Forrest was P4P at the time and a serious fighter before Mayorga got to him, and i think he beat Mayorga in the rematch anyway, i belive the cards were very close.

Too many loses and his big fights, sorry this is a no brainer!

[Technical_Skill]

Too many loses and his big fights, sorry this is a no brainer!

He had too many losses because he fought too many World Class fighters, im sorry, PBF is my fav fighter but...

Genaro Hernandez, Zab Judah, Castillo x2 and Corrales

doesnt equal or beat

De La Hoya x2 (prime) Vernon Forrest x2 (Prime) Winky Wright x2 (prime) and Fernando Vargas x2

[GunStar]

He had too many losses because he fought too many World Class fighters, im sorry, PBF is my fav fighter but...

Genaro Hernandez, Zab Judah, Castillo x2 and Corrales

doesnt equal or beat

De La Hoya x2 (prime) Vernon Forrest x2 (Prime) Winky Wright x2 (prime) and Fernando Vargas x2

Like I said he lost 5 of those fights, Genaro Hernandez, Zab Judah, Castillo x2, Oscar on May 5TH and Corrales are all better then Forrset and Vargas.

[Technical_Skill]

Like I said he lost 5 of those fights, Genaro Hernandez, Zab Judah, Castillo x2, Oscar on May 5TH and Corrales are all better then Forrset and Vargas.

No way was Diego Corrales ever more Skilled Than Vernon Forrest.

Prime De La Hoya twice beats 'end of the road' De La Hoya now.

[riza]

mosley moving up 2 divisions and beating a prime de la hoya alone is more impressive than mayweather beating corrales and chavez, and also losing to castillo.

btw mosley beat forrest in the rematch, and also gave winky a better fight in the rematch than anyone else has in recent years.

also a prime vernon forrest imo had the style to beat floyd aswell.