Is Pacquiao-Marquez the closest triology you've ever seen?

[lebrick]

norton to ali was pac's jmm, no doubt..

[GoogleMe]

I think Ali - Frazier were on of the closer triologies.

[Toney Loc]

I had Morales edging the 3rd fight.

I had Barrera winning all three.

[IronDanHamza]

I had Barrera winning all three.

Really?

I felt he won the first one and there's a good argument he won the 3rd but I felt the second was clearly Morales' win.

[Toyman]

I had pac winning all 3 fights.

the 3rd fight of course, he won big 116-112 on my card.


the 1st and 2nd fights he won by either 1 or 3 points in each of them

113-112 or 114-111 in the 1st

114-113 or 115-112 in the 2nd

out of generosity to jmm, i gave him the extra rounds in each to make it closer than reality.

in none of the 3 do i see jmm winning.

and the judges agree with me; after 3 fights and 9 judges the records read

6 judges for pac
2 for jmm
1 draw


6-2-1 doesnt sound that close to me, and considering that at best, i had jmm only within a point of pac then no, i dont think its that close of a trilogy.

[Toney Loc]

Really?

I felt he won the first one and there's a good argument he won the 3rd but I felt the second was clearly Morales' win.

I thought he won the first one and clearly won the third. The second one was really close, either couldve have gotten the decision. I am biased, though. I love love Barrera. :grill:

[The Surgeon]

Im in agreement that Ali vs Norton And Barrera vs Morales were both closer trilogies than JMM vs Pac, Ive had Marquez being the superior fighter throughout though they have been close for sure