Who is higher on the ATG list: Floyd Mayweather (so far) or Roberto Duran?

[MotorCityJaguar]

Quote:

Originally Posted by MotorCityJaguar

Obviously Duran is higher in a p4p list. But if you think that Duran was naturally smaller than Mayweather you are an idiot

No, Duran is a smaller man.

Duran started at bantamweight, Floyd started 3 divisions bigger at junior lightweight.

Floyd is taller with a much longer reach than Duran.

Floyd looked drained at the weigh-in yesterday, he's having trouble making 147 now.

Floyd grew into a big welterweight, he couldn't even make the catch-weight when he fought the much smaller JM Marquez. Floyd refused to fight Ricky Hatton at 140 or at a catchweight between 140 and 147.

Duran was 16 when started at bantamweight. Mayweather at 16 was in the flyweight division in the amateur

And Mayweather isn't a big welterweight




Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[Welsh Jon]

Ha why is this even a question?

It's Duran by some distance

[- Ram Raid -]

Fan favourite Vs the man fans love to hate? Purely objective this one. No emotional decisions.

[Elroy1]

STILL GOING?

OMG!

I'm far from a Floyd fan but hey, he has dominated one of the most stellar resumes of any boxer.

Conversely, Duran struggled/lost to ALL of the fab 4 (even quit once), none of which were lb for lb as good as Floyd ever.

And H2H Duran stands no chance whatsoever!

Am I missing something?

Duran's ATG status is not worth one drop of piss in the desert next to Mayweathers.

Indisputable FACT!

Get over it!

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Dont ever compare this quitter to Floyd.


TOP 5 DOA

[TMTForever]

Yeah, unified titles with who Victor Ortiz ? Carlos Baldomir? Fringe contenders? 35 year old Oscar? Lol. Seriously go choke on a dick and stop breathing. You're not an asset to society with that logic.

you don't "represent society" society saw duran say no mas, society has seen floyd unify the 147 and 154 titles at 37 years of age..duran couldn't come close to that in his career..

[slipcatchroll]

Dont ever compare this quitter to Floyd.


TOP 5 DOA

Got knocked out ice cold by Hearns as well, lest we forget


TOP 5 DOA

[slipcatchroll]

you don't "represent society" society saw duran say no mas, society has seen floyd unify the 147 and 154 titles at 37 years of age..duran couldn't come close to that in his career..

Longest reigning champion as well, lest we forget

[Wizardsh]

STILL GOING?

OMG!

I'm far from a Floyd fan but hey, he has dominated one of the most stellar resumes of any boxer.

Conversely, Duran struggled/lost to ALL of the fab 4 (even quit once), none of which were lb for lb as good as Floyd ever.

And H2H Duran stands no chance whatsoever!

Am I missing something?

Duran's ATG status is not worth one drop of piss in the desert next to Mayweathers.

Indisputable FACT!

Get over it!

Wow talk about a moron must be larry cousin

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Duran..

Better wins
Better fighter
Better opponents