Who has faced more adversity since 2009: Money Mayweather or Chino Maidana?

[punchr]

Mayweather
2009 - Juan Manuel Marquez
2010 - Shane Mosley
2011 - Victor Ortiz
2012 - Miguel Cotto
2013 - Robert Guerrero
2013 - Canelo Alvarez
2014 - Marcos Maidana

Maidana
2009 - Victor Ortiz
2010 - Amir Khan
2011 - Erik Morales
2012 - Devon Alexander
2012 - Jesus Soto Karass
2013 - Josesito Lopez
2013 - Adrien Broner
2014 - Floyd Mayweather

Which boxer, Mayweather or Maidana, has faced more adversity in their matches since 2009?

What do you think? and why?

Vote and discuss, gentlemen of NSB.

[LoadedWraps]

Maidana without question. The title makes it sound like this is about adversity, Maidana has crossed paths with lions, it's not close to close. Your OP however makes it sound like you are comparing resumes, because names alone don't tell you if a fighter went through adversity or not, so if the point is about resumes them floyd wins by a landslide.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Maidana has faced more adversity because he's an average fighter

[Larry the boss]

Floyd clearly has faced the better fighters,excluding himself

[Syf]

Maidana without question. The title makes it sound like this is about adversity, Maidana has crossed paths with lions, it's not close to close. Your OP however makes it sound like you are comparing resumes, because names alone don't tell you if a fighter went through adversity or not, so if the point is about resumes them floyd wins by a landslide.

I agree.. May has the better resume.. But chino's style necessitates that he went through more adversity, because he straight up tries to break his opponent, whereas Floyd plays the finesse angle.

[IronDanHamza]

Maidana's gone through more adversity in the sense he had up and down fights with Ortiz and Lopez, had a close fight with Morales, lost to Khan and Devon and a 6 round war with Karrass but I don't think that's really a compliment.

He's had more adversity with lesser fighters.

[ninerdude90]

Seeing as how he's been to prison, been dumped by his best friend and girlfriend, I'd say Floyd has faced much more adversity since '09.

Seriously though, It's Maidana. Dropped 3x's vs. Ortiz, in the first round against Khan, and came storming back in both fights. Plus his near retirement after the Alexander beating, plus slugfests with Karass and Lopez...he's been through quite a bit.

[bojangles1987]

Maidana, obviously, he's not as good as Mayweather.

[tangalog2200]

Seeing as how he's been to prison, been dumped by his best friend and girlfriend, I'd say Floyd has faced much more adversity since '09.

Seriously though, It's Maidana. Dropped 3x's vs. Ortiz, in the first round against Khan, and came storming back in both fights. Plus his near retirement after the Alexander beating, plus slugfests with Karass and Lopez...he's been through quite a bit.

agree 100%...

[djtmal]

Floyd clearly has faced the better fighters,excluding himself

I got a question for you. Has Floyd ever faced a tall, rangy fighter with some boxing abililty. ir Please not Corrales because Corrales was more of a puncher than anything. More like a Forrest or Paul Williams