Imagine the IBHOF isn't a huge joke is Cotto definitly in?

[zmm001]

His best wins are Mosley, Paulie and Martinez
He has loses to 2 HOFers in Money and Pac. A controversial loss to Margarito and then a bad looking loss to trout if it was up to you would he be in the hall of fame?

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Yes cotto is a HOFer....


He isn't ATG, but cotto is a lock for hall of fame and deservedly so..

[Mr.Fantastic]

Barely but his career isn't over. He does have a chance for ATG status but with the diva attitude n draining opponents. I don't see it happening.

[-PBP-]

He's a diva and has been acting like a how lately but he is without a doubt a hall of famer. I mean WTF.

[El-blanco]

Definite hof, incredible résumé, win or lose. Literally fought everyone, don't let his recent actions skew your opinion.

[HanzGruber]

Lol he's gonna be in the HOF is this really a question.

[ramplamp]

Agreed. He's a lock for the Hall, and a deserving one. 4 division champ, all-around great fighter. I don't like his and his team's negotiation tactics either, but it doesn't diminish what he's accomplished in the ring. And outside of his diva-ish demands, he seems like a good guy.

[Scott9945]

When he beat Martinez it ended any doubt. Cotto will be in the HOF.

[-Kev-]

First PR fighter to win titles in 4 weight classes. Of course he's a HOF'er. You're always gonna get major credit for being the first to do something. No matter how the Martinez win is looked at after the fact, it was still a big win and a fight he was underdog to lose in.

[Hougigo]

He'd get in either way