Roy Jones Jr. or James "Lights Out" Toney?

[T.McGrady]

Best wins:
Hopkins
Toney
Ruiz
Tarver
R.Johnson
4 division champion

Scoring criteria:
Consistency:Jones
Best wins:Toney
Accomplishments:Jones
Reaction to adversity:Toney

hmmm.....what about undefeated griffin? The guy who beat toney twice? Jones was the first man to beat griffin WITH A FASHION WAY!

[General Zod]

This is about what it comes down to. It's close but overall Jones has it simply because of Toney's laziness really.

True, Toney has thrown away a lot of years, 1997-2002, I cant believe he was dumb enough to be roided against Ruiz

[General Zod]

hmmm.....what about undefeated griffin? The guy who beat toney twice? Jones was the first man to beat griffin WITH A FASHION WAY!

Toney should be 1-1 with Griffin, he was robbed in the second fight
Jones is also 1-1 with Griffin

Personally I don't think much of Griffin, maybe he would of achieved more if Futch stayed with him, but Futch walked after Jones I

[IMDAZED]

Jones by a very good margin.

[T.McGrady]

Toney should be 1-1 with Griffin, he was robbed in the second fight
Jones is also 1-1 with Griffin

Personally I don't think much of Griffin, maybe he could of achieved more if Futch stayed with him, but Futch walked after Jones I

Here we go again! roy lost by DQ, and got his revenge by 1st round KO. Toney lost 2 times by UD. That's a fact.

Toney is one of my favourite fighters ever, but come on..Jones beat him when he was P4P the best in the world.

[General Zod]

Here we go again! roy lost by DQ, and got his revenge by 1st round KO. Toney lost 2 times by UD. That's a fact.

He deserved to be dqed for what he did, whether or not he got his revenge doesn't change it
Toney was clearly robbed in the second fight, it doesn't matter anyway Griffin was a class B fighter anyway

Toney is one of my favourite fighters ever, but come on..Jones beat him when he was P4P the best in the world.

We are talking about their overall careers work, just because you lose to someone doesn't mean their resume becomes better than yours.
But I agree with Bennyst, Toney has hurt his case based on his inconsistency

[General Zod]

Jones by a very good margin.

I go with Jones overall body of work, due to Toney throwing away a lot of his years, but I would class Toney's best wins as better than Jones's best wins.

[T.McGrady]

He deserved to be dqed for what he did, whether or not he got his revenge doesn't change it
Toney was clearly robbed in the second fight, it doesn't matter anyway Griffin was a class B fighter anyway

We are talking about their overall careers work, just because you lose to someone doesn't mean their resume becomes better than yours.
But I agree with Bennyst, Toney has hurt his case based on his inconsistency

Roy's career is better. Former HW,LH(Undisputed),SMW,MD chmapion of the world, 90's FOTY, Never lost in his prime(except the 1st griffin bout).

He Beat:
Hopkins
Toney
Tarver
Ruiz
R.Johnson
McCallum
Virgil Hill

But i have to say Toney fought the better competion.

[General Zod]

Roy's career is better. Former HW,LH(Undisputed),SMW,MD chmapion of the world, 90's FOTY, Never lost in his prime(except the 1st griffin bout).

He Beat:
Hopkins
Toney
Tarver
Ruiz
R.Johnson
McCallum
Virgil Hill

But i have to say Toney fought the better competion.

I agree, which is what BennyST said as well

you class beating that version of McCallum as a great win?

[Equinox]

Roy by mile.