Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Comments Thread For: Amir Khan’s Chance To Definitively Claim The Lead

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Comments Thread For: Amir Khan’s Chance To Definitively Claim The Lead

    By Jake Donovan

    Ever since his title winning effort over Andriy Kotelnik two years ago, Amir Khan has claimed to be the best junior welterweight on the planet.

    With each passing win, his massive herd of supporters have been every bit as vocal in echoing such sentiments.

    This weekend offers the chance for the confident Brit to truly put something behind his words, as he takes on Zab Judah at the Mandalay Bay in Las Vegas (Saturday, HBO, 10PM ET/PT).

    Standing in the way of such a boast becoming a definitive reality has been Timothy Bradley, an undefeated American who entered the title fray a year ahead of Khan and has repeatedly bumped off top competition.

    However, Bradley’s career progress has come to a screeching halt thanks to an ongoing promotional contract dispute with Gary Shaw Productions and Thompson Boxing, both of whom claim there’s still time left on the clock.

    Until it gets sorted out, all Bradley can do is sit back and watch the parade go by, his top spot (which isn’t definitively his to begin with) in jeopardy as the best of the rest in the division march onward.

    Leading the charge is none other than Khan, perhaps the only other junior welterweight in the world who boasts a resume that matches – if not trumps – that of the sculpted American.

    The great debate began just two years ago, when Manny Pacquiao laid claim to the lineal junior welterweight crown with his rousing second round knockout of then-reigning king Ricky Hatton, only to immediately bolt to the welterweight division.

    At the time, Khan had yet to make his mark and in fact was still in the recovery stage of his career after getting blitzed in less than a minute by Breidis Prescott just a year prior. [Click Here To Read More]

  • #2
    bradley has done more sorry khan was ko by a bum and has only beaten 1 top fighter in madaina at 140

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by PRBOXINGCOTTO View Post
      bradley has done more sorry khan was ko by a bum and has only beaten 1 top fighter in madaina at 140
      You must not follow 140 then. Many people feel Kotelnik beat Alexander, even Floyd Mayweather. So does that mean Alexander isn't good on Bradley's resume?

      Oh ok then so Holt lost to Mabuza after who Judah beat.

      Oh ok the Peterson who beat nobody at the time, and still hasn't beat any key now.

      Oh ok the Witter who already lost to Zab Judah. Who also didn't beat anyone of note really.

      Oh so pretty much no one at 140 has a good resume.

      Comment


      • #4
        Kotelnik, Malignaggi, Maidana, McCloskey were all ranked in the top 10 when Khan fought them.

        And Judah is yet another top 10 boxer, Khan is fighting.

        If Khan beats Judah, I will have him as #1.

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by PRBOXINGCOTTO View Post
          bradley has done more sorry khan was ko by a bum and has only beaten 1 top fighter in madaina at 140


          At 140, Khan's and Bradley's resumes are pretty close to each other.

          And Maidana isn't the only top fighter, Khan has beaten. IMO, Kotelnik is the best fighter Khan has beaten till this date. In fact, I rate Kotelnik higher than any fighter Bradley has fought.

          Comment


          • #6
            Khan does not pass Bradley unless he beats him,or Bradley stays inactive for more then a yr..Other then that Khan does not deserve the spot end of story...

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by Mojo Jojo View Post


              At 140, Khan's and Bradley's resumes are pretty close to each other.

              And Maidana isn't the only top fighter, Khan has beaten. IMO, Kotelnik is the best fighter Khan has beaten till this date. In fact, I rate Kotelnik higher than any fighter Bradley has fought.
              It would be dumb to do so..Alexander like him or not unified two belts,Holt was also ranked above Kottie when Bradley fought him...See what you have to look at is where every fighter was/ranked when Bradley fought umm..Kottie and Maidana are Khan's best wins to date,if Khan beats Judah he would be on level with Bradley imo but not pass him...Once again look at where everyone Bradley fought was ranked at when he fought umm it tells more of the story to why Bradley even if Khan beats him still should be rank ahead of him..

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by ElderlyBeater View Post
                You must not follow 140 then. Many people feel Kotelnik beat Alexander, even Floyd Mayweather. So does that mean Alexander isn't good on Bradley's resume?

                Oh ok then so Holt lost to Mabuza after who Judah beat.

                Oh ok the Peterson who beat nobody at the time, and still hasn't beat any key now.

                Oh ok the Witter who already lost to Zab Judah. Who also didn't beat anyone of note really.

                Oh so pretty much no one at 140 has a good resume.
                Way to some it up there.Witter beat Kottie..Alexander a unified Champ,Holt was a Champion was Maidana??Peterson fought to a draw with Ortiz who weighed in as a Jr MW when they fought and imo lost to Peterson..Zab beat Witter yes but that was a long time ago..Bradley resume is better,fought more Champions and fought higher ranked fighters..Look at where everyone was ranked when the fights we're talking about took place..It tells the story...

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by Rome-By-Ko View Post
                  Khan does not pass Bradley unless he beats him,or Bradley stays inactive for more then a yr..Other then that Khan does not deserve the spot end of story...
                  I have Khan and Bradley even right now after Khan beats Judah gets another strap and adds yet another top contender at 140 to his resume he surpasses Bradley.

                  Bradley has fought twice in 2 years and only once at 140, in the mean time Khan will have wins over 4 top 10 ranked 140lb fighters in Malignaggi, Maidana, McCloskey and Judah. Realisticly at this point no one can claim Bradley is no1 in the division until he beats the much more active Khan.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by Rome-By-Ko View Post
                    Way to some it up there.Witter beat Kottie..Alexander a unified Champ,Holt was a Champion was Maidana??Peterson fought to a draw with Ortiz who weighed in as a Jr MW when they fought and imo lost to Peterson..Zab beat Witter yes but that was a long time ago..Bradley resume is better,fought more Champions and fought higher ranked fighters..Look at where everyone was ranked when the fights we're talking about took place..It tells the story...
                    Having a belt means little Maidana is undoubtedly the better name to have on your resume than Holt.

                    Zab beat Witter yes but that was a prime 27 year old undefeated Witter.

                    Wait you had Peterson winning the Ortiz fight? Your credibility is sailing off into the sunset.
                    Last edited by -Lowkey-; 07-20-2011, 05:54 AM.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X
                    TOP