How high of an ATG would manny be if beat Mayweather?

[Pac=Duran]

Beyond the fight with Genaro Hernandez, that's not really true. Not saying that everyone that Floyd's fought will go into the IBHOF, but he's fought world-level competition for the last 17 years of his career.

Outside of maybe the Emmanuel Augustus fight, you can't really point to a single slouch of Floyd's resume post-Genaro Hernandez. Look for yourself.

Hernandez and Coralles wouldn't even be in the top 15 individual wins of Manny Pacquiao's career but they're Floyd's best and 2nd best wins lol

[Sheppirino]

If either fighter dominates each other easily then that fighter would definitely deserve to be in the top 15 of all time P4P list. Yes, they are both slightly past their primes but they would both pretty much whip anyone in their division aside from each other. Just my humble opinion.

[B Phontain]

No he's not.

he has his built in excuse for when manny loses. He's not really telling you, he's tryna convince himself of it

[Double_L]

He lost four fights to Marquez,

Lol @ you starting your post with that, then expecting anyone to take you seriously, besides haters and... you know. Your preceding post reeked of haterade but then you went ahead and one-upped yourself.

[Weltschmerz]

He is one of the greatest ever, win or lose come May 2nd.

[jas]

Alright guys

Write your top 25 lists and why each fighter is in each position

[Weltschmerz]

Morales, Barrera, Marquez, all of them in their prime. De La Hoya and Mosley.
Cotto, Hatton, Margarito, Bradley.

A win over Mayweather would make Manny's career complete.

[cactusEG]

number 4 of all time !

[Johnwoo8686]

Morales, Barrera, Marquez, all of them in their prime. De La Hoya and Mosley.
Cotto, Hatton, Margarito, Bradley.

A win over Mayweather would make Manny's career complete.

Morales and Barrera were both on the slide when Manny got to them, they had 50 and 60 fights respectively and many of them being wars. And Morales beat him the first time. JMM was already over 30 when Manny fought him the first time and he could only get a draw LOL.

Bradley is a good win but Bradley was outgunned in every physical department. Manny is definitely a top 40 fighter, maybe top 30.

[Weltschmerz]

Morales and Barrera were both on the slide when Manny got to them, they had 50 and 60 fights respectively and many of them being wars. And Morales beat him the first time. JMM was already over 30 when Manny fought him the first time and he could only get a draw LOL.

Bradley is a good win but Bradley was outgunned in every physical department. Manny is definitely a top 40 fighter, maybe top 30.

Should he beat Mayweather in style, it would definitely be icing on the cake. Unfortunately, I foresee a decision win for Mayweather. The problem is the size and reach advantage Mayweather has over Manny. Manny needs to tag him. Hopefully Roach has a great master plan, in order for Manny to get to him. Then again, Maidana got to him a couple times, Mayweather looks to have slowed down. If Maidana could get to him, why shouldn't the faster and much more refined Manny get to him? Yes!!!