Who was the greatest Jack Dempsey of all time?

[SBleeder]

Poll coming.

[BigStereotype]

Manassa Mauler > Nonpareil

[Wild Blue Yonda]

Non-Pareil > Manassa Mauler.

However, it is hard not to be intoxicated by the latter Dempsey, & he did indeed have a memorable career.

[McGoorty]

My decision

1. Non Pariel,-----on skill level

. ,

[Marchegiano]

Nonpareil is the p4p king of LPRR. His resume is better. His chin is better. He's more fit, and has a much deeper bag of tricks. NP is both a boxer and a slugger. Similar to Joe Louis, not in style, but ability to cover the full spectrum of ranges with superior offense and defense. IMO NP is not only the greatest Jack Dempsey, but in a head to head 5'8" 150lbs or so of John Kelly is too much Kelly for Will Harrison to handle. I rate Will in the top 10 HW's. I rate John in the top 5 p4p.