Better resume Jones at 160-168 or Floyd 130-135

[flyest1]

Both were beast at those weight classes. Who do yall think gets the nod.

No this isn't a stupid thread, lol

[bojangles1987]

Roy signature wins: Bernard Hopkins, James Toney(#1 P4P at time)

Floyd signature wins: Diego Corrales, Jose Luis Castillo

I'll take Roy's two rather easy wins over no question all time greats and complete domination of any other solid contenders over Floyd's resume.

[-EX-]

Roy: Hopkins, Toney, Pazienza

Floyd: Castillo, Corrales, Corley, Augustus, Hernandez

Some might disagree but I'm goin wit Floyd. Add in the fact Bernard was still a little green...

[vegeta23]

Hopkins, Toney, Pazienza are hall of famers and the guys floyd are not.By the way toney i think was #3 on the pound for pound list.But not sure

[boxasmash]

toney>>> any mayweather win.

[CUFreeze]

LOL Roy by a landslide

[Frank Martin]

Roy's better. Win over Toney & Hopkins is something that Floyd's resume dont have.

[bojangles1987]

Hopkins, Toney, Pazienza are hall of famers and the guys floyd are not.By the way toney i think was #3 on the pound for pound list.But not sure

He might have been but I think he was either 1 or 2, and after the win was the start of Jones's reign as #1 P4P.