Is sergio martinez an ATG?

[Skip Bayless]

I believe so. the reason i like martinez is he represents all that is good about boxing. he isnt a paper champ, he fought his way to the top. he doesnt get the media coverage alot of overrated bums gets. he represents the struggle

notable wins:

kermit cintron (i dont care what boxrec says, he won)
paul williams
kelly pavlik
dzinziruk
barker
macklin
chavez
murray (soon to be)

[illmaticfighter]

smh noooooooo

[mathed]

If he beats Murray, Chavez jr again and Floyd, I'd say he deserves that honor. If he retires after the Murray fight, I'd say he is one of the best boxers of the last 10 years or so.

[RapidFire26]

I like him, but he is not an all-time great as of yet imo.

[daggum]

If he beats Murray, Chavez jr again and Floyd, I'd say he deserves that honor. If he retires after the Murray fight, I'd say he is one of the best boxers of the last 10 years or so.

what will that prove? beating b level fighters doesn't make you an all time great unless your name is floyd mayweather and last i checked sergio's name was not floyd mayweather.

[joseph5620]

I believe so. the reason i like martinez is he represents all that is good about boxing. he isnt a paper champ, he fought his way to the top. he doesnt get the media coverage alot of overrated bums gets. he represents the struggle

notable wins:

kermit cintron (i dont care what boxrec says, he won)
paul williams
kelly pavlik
dzinziruk
barker
macklin
chavez
murray (soon to be)

Not even close and I like Martinez..

[Larry the boss]

no.................

[LeG00N]

no.......... he's not even a HOF

[daggum]

no.................

is that why floyd won't fight him? i'm sure if he was an all time great he would be in a rush to fight him. come on sergio step your game up! beat berto then maybe you can get a floyd fight!

[Larry the boss]

is that why floyd won't fight him? i'm sure if he was an all time great he would be in a rush to fight him. come on sergio step your game up! beat berto then maybe you can get a floyd fight!

No it may have to do with the fact that he is a damn Middleweight