As a diehard Pac and Big fan: Im sorry Em is better than both.

[Sweet Pea 50]

Not even fuken close..eminem is overated as ****...ghostface has more classics them eminem

I'd pick Gza over GFK. But that's just me.

[MACAQUEINBLACK]

Its time to get over the fact that hes a corny white boy people.

That dude can RAP.

Period.

It's nothing to do with him being white.



He's not the only white rapper out there who was ever Great.


Apathy, B, Apathy.

[Derranged]

Eminem had to more time to advance his ability.

[-The Glove-]

C'mon man, you serious? I know you from Detroit and all, but Pac and Big's body of work is much greater than Eminem's. If rapping was based purely on lyrical skills, Eminem would win hands down. But that's the beauty of rap and music in general-there's so many things to consider. Delivery, flow, content, story-telling ability, etc.

[Mushashi]

As far as the topic goes. Eminem may be more technically proficient than Pac, but Pac had so much raw emotion. The dude had this crazy duality about him but didn't seem fake, something very hard to do. He could speak like a preacher but then also take it to some O.G. ****. As far as B.I.G., he was just as good technically as Em IMO and I liked his flow better, dude was smooth.

You beat me to it. Couldn't agree more.

[Joeyzagz]

Dre?

Producing, maybe, but rapping?

And no Scarface, but Lil' Wayne?

LOL.

Dr dre produced the following albums:

NWA Straight Outta Compton
The Chronic
Doggystyle5
Dre 2001
Marshall Mathers LP
50 Cent Get rich or die tryin

So basically, Eminems #1 album, 50's number 1 album, Snoops number 1 album, Cube and Eazy's number 1 songs and 2pacs number 1 song.

Dre is at or near the top of the genre.

[CrackYourJaw]

Dr dre produced the following albums:

NWA Straight Outta Compton
The Chronic
Doggystyle5
Dre 2001
Marshall Mathers LP
50 Cent Get rich or die tryin

So basically, Eminems #1 album, 50's number 1 album, Snoops number 1 album, Cube and Eazy's number 1 songs and 2pacs number 1 song.

Dre is at or near the top of the genre.

I said at producing, maybe. But definitely not at rapping, which we're talking about in this thread.

[Addition]

Ems the shit, no doubt about it BUT I wouldn't say he's better than Pac or Big.

Em's defo top 20 of all time, and could probably sneak into the top 10 list, personally I would have him on my top 10 list.

[gingeralbino]

2pac and biggie had the advantage (well u know what i mean) of being killed when they were still on top.
If someone put a bullet through Eminem's head after the eminem show, he'd be rated 10x better than he is today

[pelonxsoldier28]

Pac died 14 years ago and his music is still selling like crazy, do you really think Em could do the same? Hell naw. Em had some good songs but no way in hell does he compare to Pac or Big. You can't be riding down the street bumping Em, you'd get laughed at.