Who was greater or all-time? Mike Tyson vs James "Lights Out" Toney

[ATG Fighter]

Lights out is the most entertaining trash talker

[Wlad Klitschko]

Toney easily greater, prime for prime head 2 head though you have to go with Tyson. Unfortunately Tyson's prime lasted an entire 8 months, and Toney will have been relevant for 3 decades.

[da beatdown]

Never seen a wrecking ball like Tyson before, Frazier bob n weave but way quicker, combos crispier, the fear he put into men.......amazing. But with that said James Toney has been reinventing himself time and again. Highly skilled,Ring I.Q. thru the roof, slick counter puncher,( had that shoulder roll thing that Floyd does now)and at 168 was something to see. ...James Toney gets my vote.

[da beatdown]

Toney easily greater, prime for prime head 2 head though you have to go with Tyson. Unfortunately Tyson's prime lasted an entire 8 months, and Toney will have been relevant for 3 decades.

LOL...seriously...We know Toney wouldnt have been scared so already thats strike 1 for tyson. Strike 2 Toney's never been knocked out and strike 3 once the fight gets past round 5 or 6 Tysons gassed. Shoulder roll over hand right, Toney counters Tyson all night...simple

[King Of Ring]

tyson all the way