Is Shane Mosley a HOF?

[Kevin Jesus]

Mosley is a HOF'er easily. A lot of other bums make it and are praised like they were all that and SSM is way better than a lot of those.

[Stoppage]

He is in my book.

[Doctor_Tenma]

Nah-uh, you didn't!

My problem with this thread is that the TS REALLY thinks and knows that Shane is a HOF, but is denying it just to point out his love for PBF. You're not a true boxing fan if you think Shane isn't a HOFer.

I didn't say, not impressed with his overall resume. Notice I haven't voted

[koboy]

Mosley has had a very good career with both high-points and low. His career isn't spectacular but it is note-worthy. All of which would have earned him a place in the HOF.

But any fighter that has used roids in a sanctioned fight should lose that eligibility and be banned from consideration. This includes any fighter, not just Mosley, who has fought a sanctioned fight under the influence of chemical enhancements.

There has to be a line in the sand, when it comes to the HOF, otherwise you diminish its value and distinction.

Great point. But I think the TS is only talking recordwise.

[koboy]

I didn't say, not impressed with his overall resume. Notice I haven't voted

Classic case of a lie covering up another lie. Shovels are on sale at Home Depot. LOL!

[PAC-BOY]

Great point. But I think the TS is only talking recordwise.

TS was hoping most would say hes not, so he could1234 have a reason why Duckweather shouldn't fight him...

[jrv1932]

If he does get in then clemens, arod, sosa, bonds, mcgwire, marion jones, etc. must get in the hof in their sports. There shouldnt be a double standard. We dont know how long he used roids. Shane used to be my fav fighter behind roy jones before the steroid thing came out. I lost alot of respect. The oscar 2nd fight should have at least been wiped out.

[Clyde Barrow]

Christ, PBF nuthuggers on this forum are disgusting.

[savorduhflavor]

The only argument that can be made for him not being in the HOF is the steroid thing.

Accomplishment wise...it's really a very stupid question. The HOF in boxing is REALLY easy to get in to. Mosley passes with flying colors.

[Doctor_Tenma]

I'd prefer if someone explained. All I'm hearing is ofcourse.