Tweet
A simple thread in which if you watch a fight and score it you then post the results here, and others can debate.
-
-
I have dug out some old scorecards from some contentious fights. I must concede, I haven't sat down with these bouts in an awful long time (some of them, more than three years), but I can say I've scored all of them at least twice in the past. Here goes...
De La Hoya-Whitaker: De La Hoya by 1
De La Hoya-Trinidad: De La Hoya by 3
De La Hoya-Quartey: Even
De La Hoya-Mosley II: De La Hoya by 2
De La Hoya-Sturm: Sturm by 2
Bowe-Holyfield II: Bowe by 1
Lewis-Holyfield II: Lewis by 2
Lewis-Mercer: Lewis by 3
Jones-Tarver I: Even
Holmes-Norton: Holmes by 3
Pacquiao-Marquez I: Pacquiao by 2
Pacquiao-Marquez II: Marquez by 2
------------
De La Hoya-Whitaker --- De La Hoya UD12. Robbery? No.
De La Hoya-Trinidad --- Trinidad MD12. Robbery? Yes.
De La Hoya-Quartey --- De La Hoya SD12. Robbery? No.
De La Hoya-Mosley II --- Mosley UD12. Robbery? Yes.
De La Hoya-Sturm --- De La Hoya UD12. Robbery? Yes.
Bowe-Holyfield II --- Holyfield MD12. Robbery? No.
Lewis-Holyfield II --- Lewis UD12. Robbery? No.
Lewis-Mercer --- Lewis MD10. Robbery? No.
Jones-Tarver I --- Jones SD12. Robbery? No.
Holmes-Norton --- Holmes SD12. Robbery? No.
Pacquiao-Marquez I --- Draw. Robbery? Yes.
Pacquiao-Marquez II --- Pacquiao SD12. Robbery? No.
As you can see, some results I disagreed with, but not all I felt were robberies as a result.Last edited by Wild Blue Yonda; 01-19-2011, 08:22 PM. -
Just watched a couple of fights were the scoring and results were disputed, Cotto vs Mosley and JMM vs Pac 2
I caught alot of critisizim for my Cotto vs Mosley card at the time but ive watched it a million times and im standing by this score
Round 1: 10-9 COTTO
Round 2: 10-9 COTTO
Round 3: 10-10 EVEN
Round 4: 10-9 COTTO
Round 5: 10-9 COTTO
Round 6: 10-9 COTTO
Round 7: 10-9 COTTO
Round 8: 10-9 COTTO
Round 9: 9-10 MOSLEY
Round 10: 9-10 MOSLEY
Round 11: 10-9 COTTO
Round 12: 9-10 MOSLEY
TOTAL - 117-112 COTTO
I felt Miguel had the better start and took the opener, The second was closer but i gave it to Cotto with his big Left cross nicking the round. I couldnt split them in the third - Even Jack Mosley said it was even and was happy as if he knew theyd lost the first 2. The fourth i prefered Cotto's work, The 5th was a big round for Cotto, The sixth he took again this timed maily based on strong right hands, Round Seven was close but i liked Miguel and he was tagging Shane as he was backing up all round, Another close round in the eighth, the nineth was Mosleys and he had Cotto backing up with a mouth injury, tho it was made close and Cotto scored with a big left at the end. Round ten belonged to Shane IMO i liked his right hand bombs but Manny Steward thought it was a Cotto round or even. In the eleventh Miguel pulled it back landing the cleaner harder shots off of the back foot but in the twelfth Miguel was backing up too much without scoring too much and Mosley took the roundComment
-
I scored Leonard Hagler last night and came up with this.
Round 1 - Sugar Ray Leonard
Round 2 - Sugar Ray Leonard
Round 3 - Marvin Hagler
Round 4 - Sugar Ray Leonard
Round 5 - Even
Round 6 - Sugar Ray Leonard
Round 7 - Marvin Hagler
Round 8 - Marvin Hagler
Round 9 - Marvin Hagler
Round 10- Marvin Hagler
Round 11- Marvin Hagler
Round 12 - Sugar Ray Leonard
Total - 114 - 115 HaglerComment
-
I will try and watch that this wkend and post my score. I know i had it tight but i think i was with u in that Hagler squeaked itOriginally posted by Barnburner View Post
Not gonna tear my Mosley vs Cotto card apart?Comment
-
-
Alot of people felt Mosley was ROBBED, i hate how that word gets thrown about! But im of the opinion not only did the right man win but it was clear, most of the rounds were pretty well contended but Cotto did the better work for meOriginally posted by Barnburner View PostComment
-
Here is mycard for Juan Mauel Marquez vs Manny Pacquaio 2
Round 1 - 10-9 JMM
Round 2 - 10-9 JMM
ROUND 3 - 8-10 PAC
Round 4 - 9-10 PAC
Round 5 - 10-9 JMM
Round 6 - 10-9 JMM
Round 7 - 9-10 PAC
Round 8 - 10-9 JMM
Round 9 - 9-10 PAC
Round 10 - 9-10 PAC
Round 11 - 10-9 JMM
Round 12 - 10-9 JMM
TOTAL - 114-113 MARQUEZComment
-
How did you score this exactly, you think DLH won 7 and drew 1?Originally posted by Wild Blue Yonda View PostComment
-
Comment