In your opinion who's better Aaron Rodgers or Peyton Manning?

[-MAKAVELLI-]

I know you miss the Rich Gannon years huh Mak?

Rich Ganon, Hostetler...been over a decade since my Raiders have had a decent QB

[Danny Gunz]

Rich Ganon, Hostetler...been over a decade since my Raiders have had a decent QB

Looks like you guys will be in the Bridgewater sweepstakes though.

[Regeza]

I used to for some reason dislike Manning, now he is my favorite to watch.

[_original_]

Manning, but take into consideration where I reside.

[~AK49~]

At this point Peyton is arguably goat, atleast definitely in the convo, while Rodgers is not.

And thats not a knock on rodgers

[the mesiah]

Regular season-Peyton manning , playoffs-aaron Rodgers..

[New England]

manning. he makes everybody around him better.

[Bushbaby]

As far as arm strength, it's Rogers hands down. However Manning is a finesse qb who knows how to win games. Tough choice but I'd say Rogers right now based on sheer physical advantages.

[Enayze]

Peyton Manning and Tom Brady are neck and neck, with Rodgers and Brees immediately below them.

[Golden]

Easily Manning.